This feature seems like a no-brainer to me. Is there any plan to implement this?
I write so much stupid stuff, can I please clean up the mess?
<3 SN
pull down to refresh
This feature seems like a no-brainer to me. Is there any plan to implement this?
I write so much stupid stuff, can I please clean up the mess?
<3 SN
My suggestion would be following implementation.
Post earned: +1000 sats Deletion fee/donation: -1000 sats (will be donated into daily rewards) === TOTAL: 0 satsThe reason for donating the sats to rewards is that the person that paid the sats already received their value (because presumably they already read the post). So there's no need to return the money to them. On the other hand removing post with sats is undesirable (we want to keep valuable posts ;)), so the person removing it should lose some sats.
If the author of the post already withdrew their sats from SN, then fair enough - I don't see that as a huge problem. If we would be really strict, the dialog could ask them to deposit 1000 sats to be able to delete the post... but that sounds like a bit too much.
@k00b, @kr fwiw
yeah i like this approach.
free post deletion could be available if less than 10 mins have passed and/or if no tips have been paid.
otherwise, i think the strict version of your dialog box makes sense… we really want people to keep their best posts on this site.
would be a nice bonus for the daily rewards pool.
deleted by author
deleted by author
It's planned. There's no opposition to allow deletes on my end.
Just too much to do.
PLAN HARDER
Okay.
I love SN, this is my go-to Bitcoin news place
deleted by author
deleted by author
one thing that deleting posts introduces is the question of what to do with the sats.
if i tip someone sats for their post, i’d feel disappointed if they immediately deleted it.
@calle, what do you think of making the user pay back the amount of sats they were tipped in order to delete their post?
I think the model of reddit is quite good: just delete it and don't care about the Karma. Would be a huge pita to roll back all tips for a single post. Tipped is tipped 🤷
fair point, it is a simpler appproach.
however, one difference between karma & sats is that people think twice about spending their sats, there is no downside for giving karma on reddit.
amplifying content on SN has a real cost, and comes with an implicit promise that your sats will go towards spreading the message you are supporting.
breaking that promise with users by letting anyone delete their posts for free could lead to fewer people tipping overall.
as a counter-argument, not allowing post deletion at all could also be preventing people from even posting in the first place.
sats on deleted posts could be donated to the rewards pool
This is a great idea 💡
yup, makes sense that fees for deleting a post go directly back to the best users.
Won't work though as the sats are already sent to the poster right? I think tipped is tipped, what happens after then is no one else's business.
deleted by author
deleted by author
deleted by author
deleted by author
deleted by author
deleted by author
Make all deletes replace by fee :P charge em for their mistakes
deleted by author
deleted by author
FWIW, I don't post much on Stacker News, cuz I know I can't edit or delete if it is later revealed to need an edit or delete because it's unfactual "news".
deleted by author
I second the motion for a delete button.
No one really enjoys the cringe when confronted with their “stupidity” from the past. 😅😊
I don't think you should be able to delete a comment or post from long ago.
I imagined delete to work like edit where you have 10 minutes.
Could this be one factor responsible for the high quality of content on this site? No delete = you got to write to the best of your abilities.
Good point here.
Is the ability to "delete" fiat thinking even? Do it once, do it right? Just thinking out loud...
deleted by author
deleted by author
deleted by author
Yes, exactly.
deleted by author
deleted by author
deleted by author
Yeah, we should have a delete button, but...
Not having one makes you think harder before posting something.
deleted by author
UPDATE
Posts and Comments can now be deleted:
SN release: deletes 😱, link stuff, and post duplicate stuff
#121947
deleted by author
Lol no do overs in bitcoin
deleted by author
I have been wondering the same thing. Boosting.
deleted by author
I for one don't care strongly if someone deletes a post I tipped and get to keep the sats. I already read the post and 99% of the post I read I only read once. So I got my values worth even if it's deleted later. 99% of posts probably won't be deleted as well. Let's have basic delete feature and see how we go?
deleted by author
ya feel the same about some of the things I said here also. uhm. yee. I really should delete one comment I made here cuz it uhm, it's not that I said anything that I regret or anything. Sometime I spill too much outta mi heart. I could get into trouble if somebody start searching me. uhm. not that I paranoid or anything. when u got the time @k00b when u got the time. No hurry no worry.
deleted by author
Would love this as well. It does make question what I chat about here.
deleted by author
заметил беспорядок? наведи поряток. это лишь пример того на что способен биткоин...
deleted by author
deleted by author