pull down to refresh

If USA had zero illegal aliens, would housing costs decrease?
Health care costs decrease?
Gemini:
Based on the position typically presented by the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), the article "Illegal Immigration Driving the Cost of Housing" argues that the recent influx of unauthorized immigrants significantly contributes to the nation's housing affordability crisis by increasing demand.
The primary points of the argument include:
  • Increased Housing Demand: The entry of millions of individuals into the country substantially increases the overall demand for housing. This surge in demand, without an equivalent increase in supply, inherently drives up housing prices and rents nationwide, making homes less affordable for native-born Americans.
  • Fiscal Cost: The article aligns with FAIR's broader position that unauthorized immigrants pose a significant net fiscal cost to U.S. taxpayers. These costs stem from the provision of public services, such as K-12 education for U.S.-born children of unauthorized immigrants, and the use of welfare programs and uncompensated healthcare services.
  • Rebuttal to Supply Argument: The article rejects the idea that unauthorized immigration benefits the housing market by providing cheap labor that significantly increases the supply of new homes through construction.

For additional context on this topic, watch JD Vance discuss how illegal immigrants are driving up housing prices on YouTube: JD Vance: illegal immigrants are driving up housing prices.
reply
Similarly enforcing 8 USC 1324 against all who aid, harbor or employ illegal immigrants will end illegal immigration and force those who are here to leave with those outcomes beginning in literally one day.
Within a very short period of time -- weeks to months -- there will be no illegal immigration or problem with it other than those who come with the express intent to break the law and those people we can easily deal with since by definition that's all who will be left.
Why? Because nobody is going to do 10 years in federal prison touage their "feelings" about illegal immigrants or toist them. Not one farmer will spend 10 years in the pokey so he can have cheaper labor, nor will one roofing company. They'll either hire Americans or legal immigrants because the alternative is that they do 10 years in the Graybar Motel and their business is destroyed. Likewise every US based entity or person of a foreign entity who is here in the US will stop aiding these people with clothing, food and shelter because none of them are going to willing do 10 years in the slammer either, nor will they risk that becoming a life sentence if they choose poorly on who they help and that person kills an American.
These penalties, by the way, have been on the books since the 1950s and as such enforcement is all that is required to absolutely resolve the illegal immigration problem and remove every person who is here illegally as virtually all will, if this occurs, leave on their own.
Doing this would also instantly resolve the housing cost problem because it will put five years worth of housing supply into the market immediately.
reply