That's fair. I like the Tigers. I hope some of the young players work out and they can become competitive again. Central is a weak division, won't take much. 

all things being equal i'd probably give you puljols as better overall, comparable offensive production and better defense for sure. but i'm a lifelong tigers fan, so i cannot in good conscience entertain anyone but miggy as the goat (in the last 50 years)

tnuts420

One of the best hitters for sure but I don't know about best player. No defensive or baserunning value though. Assuming we are excluding Bonds due to the steroid issue, I would probably put Trout, Griffey Jr and Puljols ahead of Cabrera. Sorry. 

grayruby

Stacker Sports- Meta Takeover- Day 3

best mlb player of the last 50 years is miguel cabrera. 2 time al mvp, 4 time al batting champ, 12 time all star, first triple crown winner in 45 seasons, and only the 3rd player in history with 3,00 hits, 500 home runs, and a batting average above .300.

i'll die on this hill