Curious about the claims myself, but Carl is def talented and the marketing around it is great. For those that don't know, he also runs the proxy that allows you to purchase Mullvad via LN. https://vpn.sovereign.engineering
It doesn't explain it. The only hint I see is here:
In Obscura, we only control the first hop and use blind third-party relays for the exit hop. The result is that we can never correlate your identity with your traffic as we don’t even see your traffic in the first place!
It sounds like they're using some kind of onion routing.
They also say they'll be open sourcing the client which should tell all about the privacy claims.
We’ll be open-sourcing all of our client code so you can look at the source code and verify that we’re doing what we say.
My understanding is it's CONNECT-IP / MASQUE where the encrypted & HTTP encapsulated IP request is sent to Obscura and the details of the request are forwarded to what they're calling a "Blind Relay" which only knows Obsucra's IP.
2-hop onion routing with pre-defined routes. No Tor consensus. Very simple.
Why are so many people desiring anonymity and privacy? What is a usual use case for it? Are they all black-hat hackers? I'm not an advocate of "if you are honest you have nothing to hide", and I certainly prefer a service without a KYC and personal info to one requiring it, but for me, this desire for anonymity looks like snake oil.
It's quite possible that soon in some countries it will become illegal to do things that you have been doing. For example using decentralized social network like Nostr will be illegal and if there's a connection that the department of wrongthink can make to your real identity, then you will be invited to provide explanation of your comments.
If you have used services like fixedfloat, then your family will be in trouble. If you have connection to Russia, then you are a lost cause, etc...
So far, there are questions about the service, especially because of the statement "the first VPN that can't track your activity".
IVPN, Mullvad are time-tested solutions that also do not require any personal information when registering. Accordingly, you can't link identity to visiting certain sites.
But this is my first impression. Need to look into it more)
Should be launching in alpha or beta by the end of this month! Jan 2024. I think the difference from Mullvad and all the others is that there is some degree of trust with Mullvad not keeping logs. Obscura doesn't require that trust because they only see the IP address you are coming from and don't even know what the exit site is.
I'll show interest, but it's a hell of an ask to use something that you claim is better than any existing solution while not having auditable code yet.
https://imgprxy.stacker.news/blr5sYHFkWPq6KI9_0lvB2CZ_s_QF-b_6o76Swbj1o0/rs:fit:600:500:0/g:no/aHR0cHM6Ly9pLnBvc3RpbWcuY2MvYzRQZ2dOSFcvazAwYi1zbi1mYmkuanBn
Curious about the claims myself, but Carl is def talented and the marketing around it is great. For those that don't know, he also runs the proxy that allows you to purchase Mullvad via LN. https://vpn.sovereign.engineering
Oh cool, I didn’t know this was the same person. Thank you for sharing!
Even though this comment is from 28 Sep, this comment was definitely worth 25% of my wallet.
Maybe I’m blind, but I missed how it works?
It doesn't explain it. The only hint I see is here:
It sounds like they're using some kind of onion routing.
They also say they'll be open sourcing the client which should tell all about the privacy claims.
My understanding is it's CONNECT-IP / MASQUE where the encrypted & HTTP encapsulated IP request is sent to Obscura and the details of the request are forwarded to what they're calling a "Blind Relay" which only knows Obsucra's IP.
2-hop onion routing with pre-defined routes. No Tor consensus. Very simple.
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-masque-connect-ip/
Obscura by name, obscura by nature 😄
Should be interesting…
it looks like a private tor
Interesting. Developed by Bitcoin Core developer, Carl Dong.
At least that's what the website says.
They take bitcoin/lightning payments. Nice!
I'll have to add to https://circularbtc.xyz when they launch.
Yes this is great. Glad to see you've calmed down a bit from earlier Delta.
Why are so many people desiring anonymity and privacy? What is a usual use case for it? Are they all black-hat hackers? I'm not an advocate of "if you are honest you have nothing to hide", and I certainly prefer a service without a KYC and personal info to one requiring it, but for me, this desire for anonymity looks like snake oil.
It's quite possible that soon in some countries it will become illegal to do things that you have been doing. For example using decentralized social network like Nostr will be illegal and if there's a connection that the department of wrongthink can make to your real identity, then you will be invited to provide explanation of your comments. If you have used services like fixedfloat, then your family will be in trouble. If you have connection to Russia, then you are a lost cause, etc...
I agree, but it's not a common case for now, certainly not enough to create the whole market
What the fuck are you smoking?
So far, there are questions about the service, especially because of the statement "the first VPN that can't track your activity".
IVPN, Mullvad are time-tested solutions that also do not require any personal information when registering. Accordingly, you can't link identity to visiting certain sites.
But this is my first impression. Need to look into it more)
Should be launching in alpha or beta by the end of this month! Jan 2024. I think the difference from Mullvad and all the others is that there is some degree of trust with Mullvad not keeping logs. Obscura doesn't require that trust because they only see the IP address you are coming from and don't even know what the exit site is.
I don't trust anything other than Mullvad at this point.
How can one bring over a different vpn provider exactly?
"Switch effortlessly Have a contract with another VPN? Bring them along. Obscura works with all WireGuard-based VPNs, from Mullvad to Proton."
Maybe it can just be a hop in the route? Or maybe they’ll honor an existing contract as if it were with them?
Very promising, we need another great VPN along IVPN and Mullvad and move away from proton
Sounds promising
"security by obscurity" gotta love that... :-) Need more details tho to have an educated opinion.
I'll show interest, but it's a hell of an ask to use something that you claim is better than any existing solution while not having auditable code yet.
Did anything ever come of this?
nice to see bitcoin as payment method since the beginning.