Are Bitcoiners too uncritical of El Salvador and Nayib Bukele???
1081 sats \ 55 comments \ @tomlaies 5 Jul 2022 bitcoin
So first of all, let me say that I was debating with myself whether to post this. I*m not sure whether this is actually my opinion and I might change it if somebody convinces me. But hear me out first:
I really think Nayib Bukele is doing something pretty problematic with El Salvador.
  • The Chivo App is basically a banking app by the government.
  • There id no proof that the dollars in the app are actually backed by dollars. We know how much Bitcoin they hold. We don't know how many dollars are in all apps combined.
  • It could be very thinly stretched classical fractional banking. How can we as Bitcoiners just ignore that?
  • It could be even worse turning a whole country in a Ponzi Sheme and the Bitcoin just a pr-stunt. The actual way to do this would be in the Bitcoin spirit with KYC Bitcoin ATMs - whicht might even have been the easier infrastructure to set up.
  • If this bold move fails it might even be worse for Bitcoin than the adoption was good for it. Slow and steady adoption might have been the safer way.
On the other hand:
  • Bitcoin adoption is just a net good
  • Even if it was a dollar based Ponzi ... it might actually work out? They could just print dollars which might catapult the economy out of being 3rd world without the actual inflation when people think they are 1:1 dollars. And ElSalvador is irrelevant in the overall money of the US. Very difficult to pull off without a collapse in the end and I don't think there is a reasonable exit strategy.
And all of this is besides Nayib Bukele being a brutal military dictator.
write
preview
related posts
47 sats \ 2 replies \ @satyagraha 5 Jul 2022 freebie
Are Bitcoiners so homogeneous in their views that this question even makes sense?
Bitcoiners, the population of the singular and homogeneous "Bitcoin community" do not agree on everything, or even, given the breadth of utility of bitcoin, very much at all.
And that's why bitcoin is great. It doesn't care.
So if you have concerns about the El Salvador situation, feel free to express them. But don't try and attribute them to all of some made up group.
reply
10 sats \ 1 reply \ @tomlaies OP 6 Jul 2022
Thanks. That really makes it better. I agree there is no one homogeneous group of Bitcoiners. There isn't even a homogenous set of opinions in most humans - and that is not a bad thing.
I just think we haven't really talked about it as Bitcoiners. And there are at least two sides to the coin. Worth discussing.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @satyagraha 12 Sep 2022 freebie
I just think we haven't really talked about it as Bitcoiners.
I appreciate your gratitude, but would have preferred your attention to the point being made more. No, there isn't a set of homogenous opinions in the even larger identity group of "most humans." Noone expects there would be. The delusion is thinking there is an homogenous "Bitcoin community," that shares a wide set of views. We don't.
"as Bitcoiners," and how, pray, is that? Who are the Bitcoiners, and when they disagree, who are the true Bitcoiners? And who decides?
72 sats \ 0 replies \ @tenderscore 6 Jul 2022
Were we or anyone in the world talking about El Salvador before this? What type of outside capital investment (critical) was there before Bukele's bitcoin gambit? What were the tourism numbers? What was the hope like? How can business work at large when gangs run the show?
They started this 9 months ago...won't this take years before we can see if it's even working? Because so far it certainly looks like it's working. The MS13 gang et al have been gutted. It's given a playbook for other latin states of what NOT to do, and what works. Bukele isn't perfect, I'm just not sure what exactly El Salvador's options were besides the recycling disaster of IMF debt and eventually unserviceable Chinese loans. How about we give it a chance?
reply
35 sats \ 0 replies \ @iguano 5 Jul 2022
Is normal that any government will try to control and centralize the bitcoin adoption. That is why the Chivo wallet is "accepted" but no bitcoin regular user will use it EVER.
The important thing happening in El Salvador is that we have the first government officially allowing people the access to sound money in more than 100 years.
reply
15 sats \ 0 replies \ @selfish_gene 5 Jul 2022
все тестируют биткоин. каждый по разному. кто то отдаёт это в правительство. кто то доверяет мелкому бизнесу. кто то просто наблюдает. это часть развития. если в сальводоре развалить я все. то это будет результат тех или иных действий которые можно учитывать в будущем.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @cryptocoin 24 Jul 2022
Here's a post on SN with an article critcal about Bukele:
El Salvador’s Embrace of Bitcoin Didn’t Bring Prosperity — It Rode in With... #48879 https://theintercept.com/2022/07/22/bitcoin-crypto-el-salvador-nayib-bukele https://archive.ph/AMsKN <-- An archive, with no paywall, no subscription requirement, and can be easier to read
reply
17 sats \ 2 replies \ @falsefaucet 5 Jul 2022
yes. everyone preaches as tho he is some great guy.
i mean shit, he refers to himself as a dictator. he brought in soldiers to help get a bill passed in their congress/house.
look at the end of the day, one should not conflate his bitcoin friendlyness with being a good leader.
these two things are not the same.
yes the bitcoin play has brought more tourism to his country and upped his GDP.
i personally am not a fan of his.
reply
18 sats \ 1 reply \ @falsefaucet 5 Jul 2022
and yeah he may have been joking when he said 'im the coolest dictator' but his actions have led credence to him being a dictator.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @falsefaucet 6 Jul 2022
but i am just an outsider looking in with my own biases.
reply
56 sats \ 2 replies \ @om 5 Jul 2022
The Chivo App is basically a banking app by the government.
But you don't have to use it. Any lightning wallet should work.
reply
51 sats \ 1 reply \ @tomlaies OP 6 Jul 2022
They don't "have to" use the Chivo app. But people loose out on free money.
That's exactly the point of central banking - technically everyone is free to participate - but it is impossible to isolate yourself from the economy around you!
It's actually the exact same thing as the stimulus checks in the USA. Nobody forced the people to accept the stimulus checks free money. But who says no to free money? And the consequences of increased money supply and inflation are inevitable - whether you participated or not.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @om 6 Jul 2022
Okay, but you can use Chivo to get free $30 and then use whatever wallet you like.
technically everyone is free to participate
There are those pesky legal tender laws though.
reply
31 sats \ 17 replies \ @falsejaguar 5 Jul 2022
He is a dictator. That's pretty much it. He has made deals with gangs, and this is all about AML KYC work arounds. No good using tradfi for sending too much dirty money, but with BTC legal tender, they can on and off ramp all they want.
reply
197 sats \ 11 replies \ @iguano 5 Jul 2022
He is a dictator if you look at him from the free world perspective. But in Latin American standards, he is a wonderful president,. and I'm pretty sure that he is one of the best in LATAM (not because of bitcoin but in all other metrics). In latin America we prefer a good dictator than another thief democratic guy. the corruption is so huge, that the metrics the people use to measure the quality of a government is different.
Venezuelan here.
reply
12 sats \ 0 replies \ @falsejaguar 5 Jul 2022
I think that it's good for him to stand up to IMF and all the rest. I think that he can attract business and development to the region and it has a real chance of helping common people. It is also insanely risky, but they don't have much to lose anyway, so I hope we can all help in our small ways just through spreading adoption of BTC!
reply
0 sats \ 9 replies \ @servandofinn 5 Jul 2022 freebie
From the free world perspective, what makes him a dictator?
1 sat \ 4 replies \ @servandofinn 5 Jul 2022 freebie
That's a bold claim. What justifies him being a dictator? I'd also request that you look up the definition of dictator so as not to waste anyone's time.
20 sats \ 2 replies \ @ember 5 Jul 2022
What happened to the volcano bonds? Where they every issued? Last I heard there were delays but haven't a seen a word about it ever since.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @cryptocoin 6 Jul 2022
.
reply
1 sat \ 0 replies \ @cryptocoin 6 Jul 2022
Lack of interest at the time. Half the funds raised for the bonds would be locked into bitcoin, and with bitcoin falling in price, and, if I remember correctly, a chunk of the funds would also go into developing the geothermal plant and mining bitcoin. We've seen public bitcoin mining operators lose 90% from their ATHs, so it's not a surprise that the bonds conceived of almost a year ago no longer have sufficient interest from investors.
I wouldn't count it out though. Geothermal is a great renewable energy source for generating power, and it is a great match for bitcoin mining since it provides a constant supply 24/7. So if bitcoin mining will help subsidize the plant (by increasing its revenue potential), it becomes a viable economic endeavor (whereas without bitcoin mining it might not get built simply because there wouldn't otherwise be sufficient demand for the generation capacity on day one when production begins).
reply
2 sats \ 6 replies \ @cryptocoin 5 Jul 2022
There id no proof that the dollars in the app are actually backed by dollars.
Correct. Just like with a bank, or with a custodial exchange, what you are seeing in the app is a ledger entry of an IOU from a custodian.
The dollars can be withdrawn from a Chivo ATM and that gives all (including the unbanked) a chance to not have to trust Chivo for more than a small period of time.
I can't say with certainty what the best approach is, but transparency with the funds would definitely not hurt.
reply
25 sats \ 5 replies \ @kilianbuhn 5 Jul 2022
So why are Bitcoiners supportive of this? We shouldn't be.
reply
2 sats \ 0 replies \ @cryptocoin 5 Jul 2022
.
reply
20 sats \ 1 reply \ @servandofinn 5 Jul 2022
No one has to use the Chivo app. I'm not sure why this is even a topic of discussion. It would be like saying that the US dollar is a failure because of the mismanagement of the Venmo app.
reply
25 sats \ 0 replies \ @tomlaies OP 6 Jul 2022
If they give away free fake money in the Chivo app.
That would be like saying the Herbalife Ponzi Sheme wasn't a bad thing because nobody was had to use it.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @cryptocoin 5 Jul 2022
There is no mandate that anyone actually use bitcoin. As legal tender, merchants are by law required to accept bitcoin for payment (given they have the technology to accommodate that ... which excludes everyone but the largest vendors), but they are not required to hold bitcoin, and conversion to fiat is not expensive.
I suspect your issue is more with Bukele than Chivo.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @cryptocoin 5 Jul 2022
I speak for nobody but myself.
I SUPPORT MOVING OFF OF CENTRAL BANK MONEY AND INTO BITCOIN --- EVEN IF THERE ARE DICTATORS WHO ALSO ARE PUSHING FOR THAT
reply
41 sats \ 0 replies \ @0260378aef 6 Jul 2022
All the ordinary people I queried in ES had mostly good things to say about the guys. This country used to have the highest murder rate in the world before Bukele, don't forget.
All the "humanitarian experts" in the west consider him evil. Forgive my skepticism.
It is true, of course, that there is a substantial anti-Bukele political faction. I'm sure it's not simple.
It could be very thinly stretched classical fractional banking. How can we as Bitcoiners just ignore that?
I don't mean to be rude, but what the fuck are you talking about? Which "bitcoiners" are ignoring that Chivo started out as a complete fuck up and to this day is mostly a government USD app, that happens to have bitcoin features? I feel like I've seen way more bitcoiners be critical of Bukele + Chivo and basically nobody uncritically support it. But it is the first country that practically uses Bitcoin with the blessing of the government, for all the limitations and flaws. So it's at least interesting, because of that.
It could be even worse turning a whole country in a Ponzi Sheme and the Bitcoin just a pr-stunt. The actual way to do this would be in the Bitcoin spirit with KYC Bitcoin ATMs - whicht might even have been the easier infrastructure to set up.
There are Chivo ATMs for changing USD<->BTC both ways, and actually they work kind of well in my experience (they also have basically no fees). I'm not sure why you said KYC (you think it should be KYC? because that's how you wrote it). Anyway, it only has KYC in as much as you need to use a phone number (and it doesn't have to be an ES phone).
Most of what you're saying seems confused.
reply
30 sats \ 1 reply \ @nullama 6 Jul 2022
I don't know any other aspect of this president or the country to be honest, but you can use any lightning wallet you want, you don't have to use Chivo Wallet.
And Bitcoin being legal tender means the people in El Salvador don't have to pay capital gains when they sell Bitcoin. Similar to how gold coins in the UK work.
Seems pretty good to me.
reply
21 sats \ 0 replies \ @tomlaies OP 6 Jul 2022
They don't "have to" use the Chivo app. But people loose out on free money.
That's exactly the point of central banking - technically everyone is free to participate - but it is impossible to isolate yourself from the economy around you!
reply
10 sats \ 0 replies \ @f6287b82CC84bcbd 6 Jul 2022
He might be wasting a lot of taxpayer dollars, but personally I'd rather see it not spent on war.
reply
10 sats \ 3 replies \ @shyfire 6 Jul 2022
To everyone calling him a dictator, keep in mind that very powerful forces do not want him to succeed in transforming the country. Your western media outlets that shape your opinion move in lock-step with these powerful forces.
I would also recommend watching this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jxvpoRgv8g&t=2714s
reply
21 sats \ 1 reply \ @tomlaies OP 6 Jul 2022
keep in mind that very powerful forces do not want him to succeed in transforming the country.
Sheeple-motive. Conspiracy theory. Bullshit.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @nice 6 Jul 2022 freebie
I don't think you need to go to "conspiracy theory" realm to think that this is highly plausible. There are surely people and institutions around the world that will want El Salvador's bitcoin experiment to fail.
21 sats \ 0 replies \ @cryptocoin 6 Jul 2022
Well, even Bukele himself had in his Twitter bio: "World's coolest dictator."
But I'ld agree he is not liked by the leftist news media publishers -- something solidified in their minds after Bukele has told the Fed chair Jerome Powell to "stop printing" and SV being among the first countries to abandon the vaccine mandates, vaccine passports, and other COVID nonsense.
reply
3 sats \ 0 replies \ @cryptocoin 5 Jul 2022
There id no proof that the dollars in the app are actually backed by dollars.
Correct. Just like with a bank, or with a custodial exchange, what you are seeing in the app is a ledger entry of an IOU from a custodian.
The dollars can be withdrawn from a Chivo ATM and that gives all (including the unbanked) a chance to not have to trust Chivo for more than a small period of time.
I can't say with certainty what the best approach is, but transparency with the funds would definitely not hurt.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @purpurato 5 Jul 2022
Not to mention the "bitcoin city" powered by a volcano! We haven't seen that kind of nonsense since the times of bitconneeect. The way to go with bitcoin was to let people use it freely, that is by NOT making regulations. But forcing it on people with laws is precisely what this is not about. Something as simple as making it tax free, or promoting companies to register there, whatever, but making it legal tender wasn't necessary. And what OP mentions on the wallet really stinks, most people on the ground confirms the problems and complain.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @tomlaies OP 5 Jul 2022
Also see this post: #41541 by @DayCentralPerk
... which I have not found confirmation sources for besides Twitter yet. But even if it is not true - it is technologically possible and just a question of time imo.
reply
0 sats \ 1 reply \ @Cornleone 6 Jul 2022 freebie
I am skeptical as well. Masks+covid mandates 🚩 🚩 🚩
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @theLeoCrypto 5 Jul 2022 freebie
His hope for the better future with #bitcoin will not perish. He's a good leader ☺️