It's just custodial lightning like WoS with the added benefit of privacy and offline usage. It's not an ecash thing, it's just lightning. The advantage over fiat is that you can choose who to trust, anyone can run a mint, could be someone you know, unlike a bank, and you can move your funds quickly. But yes I get your point, onchain bitcoin and running your node for lightning are the most trustless options, but dealing with lightning is very hard, onchain might be expensive so people go to custodial solutions. This is a problem if onchain fees get too high and becomes hard to self custody.
you can audit a lightning channel. ecash cannot be audited at all.
reply
Can't audit WoS.
reply
It's at least possible though if they published their channel states. Ecash mints are impossible to audit as it stands.
reply
How do you audit their liabilities? And you realize it would be foolish to back 1:1 user balance with LN channels, right?
So "audit their lighting" means absolutely nothing.
reply