pull down to refresh
605 sats \ 4 replies \ @ZezzebbulTheMysterious 6 Mar freebie \ on: Why Hasn’t Anyone Made a Durable Phone? tech
Phones will never be durable for the long tail, for the same reason general purpose laptops - the fast march forward of hardware technology, the slow march backward in software :-) Software grows significantly sophisticated and outlives its silicon home.
As the software on phones is mostly single consumer focused, it will always bloat bloat bloat with customer expectations.
Another problem is the limited recharge cycles of the Lithium Ion batteries.
Additionally, the iPhone started the trend of the sealing the battery for its IPX (water/intrusion resistance). So we need to either user replace, or perpetual life cells.
So we need:
- Software that doesn't grow more bloated
- Hardware that doesn't get better
- Battery chemistry that lasts a very long time or
- People accepting less water and dust resistance, and thus shortening the life
Not very likely.
great explanation, thank you!
if i understand correctly, the software piece is entirely up to the phone manufacturer, correct?
for example, if i was committed to building an android phone that didn’t have any software bloat over time, could i ensure that didn’t happen (while still ensuring my phone could communicate with others?)
reply
Mostly, but there are certain conditions that must be met for Play services, for example. Users generally want this. They also want to use Internet Banking, and other services which may require a non-root retail ROM that will pass certain checks.
Some vendors like Huawei build their ROM from open source android (ASOP), or fork it and build their own to avoid dependency. Huawei is building HarmonyOS, which may not be compat with Android in the future. (Good luck with that Huawei....).
You cannot commit to this, it is not something that can be committed to. Security updates, for example, are mandatory. Without, your phone users get hacked. (And this can be 0 touch, remote, no notification, kinda hack.).
Software is like a living thing. It grows and bloats over time. There is no didn't have bloat and still be useful to a majority of users.
reply
You may be interested to see https://www.kaiostech.com/explore/devices/
KaiOs is a commercial fork of the Firefox Mobile OS. It powers lots of devices in the developing world that are optimized for battery and price.
reply