pull down to refresh

自 + 由 + 人 = self (not sure the etymology) + reason (own reason to do things) + person

You are spot on with the meaning break down. 自由 has a literal meaning of "self reason". And a person who do things for "self reason" is free.

田 +丨= 由 (field - enter and leave)

It's doesn't have anything to do with entering and leaving the field. 由 existed way back.

https://m.stacker.news/44048

And it did not resemble 田.

https://m.stacker.news/44049

Nice reasoning though.

and thanks for showing my the true etymology. Super interesting.

reply

Yeah, I tried to make that clear (but perhaps I did not) when I said the way I 'imagined' it which is useful as a strategy to employ, particularly as a second language learner.

The book I started learning Mandarin with [Tuttle] emphasizes this approach and I believe if you look at modern dictionaries today, the character does utilize those components from the 'field' radicle.

https://m.stacker.news/44050

reply