I've enjoyed listening to J. Warner Wallace who wrote "Cold Case Christianity" - he was an atheist homicide detective who took a critical look at the gospels as he would for any of his crime scenes. 
You can check out a video of him here https://youtu.be/ajOYym3IuRk?si=mutOYPPO-FD7sDDk 
but if you're more of a book guy you can also check out the "Cold Case Christianity" book. 

> To me, it's wild that people have faith in a bunch of stories that humans put together in a book.

I'm not really sure what this means though, do you not believe in any historical accounts? The gospels are more well attested to than any other ancient manuscripts. 

If the question is about the historicity of the resurrection I would be curious what your supernatural beliefs are already.  

doubleplusgood23

DesertDave

Slestak_Jack

alter_native

Why would one believe their spiritual path is the only way?

I would have no way if knowing. Not sure how anyone would. To me, it's wild that people have faith in a bunch of stories that humans put together in a book. I don't get it. 