pull down to refresh

Heroes of Might and Magic III not in top 10 = invalid list

reply

What else is missing? I think I'd also include Max Payne, instead of GTA5 I'd do GTA:SA. Maybe Transport Tycoon...

reply

Civilization being missing is definitely a travesty. I think if the editor went back they'd realize that was a mistake.

Personally, I'd put Planescape: Torment on there, but I know it's a bit of a niche game.

I think Monkey Island deserves to be on too, as a representative of the adventure genre.

Not everyone liked it, but I'd put Heavy Rain on my list too.

Didn't realize that Heroes 3 wasn't on the list at all. Heroes 3 absolutely deserves to be on the list, it's still one of the most played old games and the top selling game on GOG I think.

reply
30 sats \ 1 reply \ @nym 8 Jan 2025

Yes it is an epic and a classic.

reply

It's still extremely popular especially in Eastern Europe

reply

This list is bad! really bad

reply

I guess it depends on a person. In my opinion this is a solid list that includes many of the games I'd select.

reply

It is missing a lot of ground breaking games. Once I saw Celeste on here and Fortnite I could tell this list is for the causal gamer.

reply

I appreciate how Celeste happened - it was first developed for pico8 console and it was such a major hit that they rewrote it for other systems and put it on Steam.

What games would you put instead?

reply

Three major games that are missing

Mario 64
Goldeneye
StarCraft

reply

StarCraft for sure. I haven't played the others...

reply

Which i understand it it doesn’t make it a top 50 game of all time. I played Celeste it’s fun but top 50 of all time?

reply

I think I would have considered Celeste, because it to some degree started a category of games.

reply

Not a bad list, most of my favourites are in the top 20. The list would have been better if if was the top 50 gaming franchises though.

reply

This is in my opinion a good list...

reply