pull down to refresh
312 sats \ 1 reply \ @hgw39 10h \ parent \ on: Quick questions about OP_RETURN? Quick answers here. bitcoin
With all due respect, I don't think you've answered the question.
Your make valid points for the justification of the increase in the limit and explain that individual nodes may be harming themselves, default settings are the norm and the transactions will be propagated anyway. You've even pointed out that the ability to configure this setting was debated anyway and some consider that it shouldn't have been added.
But the question asks something different, something I am wondering also. As a sovereign node runner in an open permissionless network, why does this PR propose to remove the ability for me to configure the mempool settings on my own node?
If I make a decision that harms myself and doesn't make any difference to the propagation of transactions, isn't that for me to decide and bear the consequences of?
It's like re-using addresses, commonly accepted as poor for privacy but there is no rule in the protocol that permits it. It's up to me to understand and accept the consequences.
With all due respect, I don't think you've answered the question.
You are right, thanks for bringing this up.
[…] why were these options taken away?
At this time, the configuration option has not been removed. There is a pull request that proposes to increase the limit and to remove the configuration option, but several reviewers have argued that the two changes should be separated or that only the limit should be changed without dropping the configuration option. I would consider this part of the pull request to be still in question.
But the question asks something different, something I am wondering also. As a sovereign node runner in an open permissionless network, why does this PR propose to remove the ability for me to configure the mempool settings on my own node?
Originally, I was in favor of dropping the configuration option, because I consider it harmful and cannot come up with a situation in which I would recommend its use to a node runner, but after talking about this with several people (including one that consulted a psychologist!), I now support leaving the configuration option in the upcoming release, although I would still prefer that it be deprecated and removed eventually.
reply