pull down to refresh

I was having a stressful conversation and absentmindedly got too close to a curb in a in-law's first generation Model S. I scuffed the front driver-side wheel up (~6 in worth) pretty bad.
It's a special car to the relative - his first Tesla, one he keeps purely for nostalgic reasons. The damage to my car borrowing reputation is eternally ruined, as it should be, but I can't figure out how to make it right.
Having owned a nostalgic, aging car, part of the value is keeping it all intact and OEM; you help the car fight time better than you can (take that Time! you cruel bastard). He probably won't let me intervene but I'd like to offer solutions if only to provide company for his anguish. afaict we have three options:
  1. get the wheel professionally repaired
    • does anyone have experience with this?
    • can it be restored to the point that it's impossible to notice even on casual inspection?
  2. buy a single replacement reproduction wheel - as good as new, spec'd to match OEM but not OEM
    • I suspect this is not very desirable given that the relative wear of the wheel will be off ever so slightly
  3. buy a full set of the OEM wheels
Are there other options? Which would you recommend?
210 sats \ 4 replies \ @Luxas 11h
If taken to get professionally repaired, there are certain repairers that are Tesla certified for curb rash restoration and will have the exact color code for the wheel so they can get it to match perfectly. Would heavily advise trying option A, but with a repairer who specializes in Teslas.
reply
10 sats \ 3 replies \ @k00b OP 10h
Thanks for the "Tesla certified" bit. I wasn't aware of that and he might not be either.
reply
Are Tesla wheels special? Or just that there’s a certain color?
reply
50 sats \ 1 reply \ @k00b OP 7h
I don’t think they’re all that special. Color matching is just always a problem I think.
reply
That’s my expectation too
reply
160 sats \ 0 replies \ @freetx 13h
I think restoration can probably go pretty far as long as there are no deep gouges.
I would offer: (a) let me try to get it professionally restored and if that doesn't work (b) I'll buy you a new wheel.
Personally, I think the offer to replace all 4 wheels is very generous but unnecessary. I think the "new shiny wheel" will wear quickly enough to match the general relative look of the others.
A few other options:
  • Get new wheel + get other 3 restored so they match better.
  • Buy a "excellent" condition used wheel, maybe it will match better with existing wheels.
reply
31 sats \ 2 replies \ @Wumbo 13h
My thought is to buy him one wheel and offer to have the other one professionally repaired.
Buying the one wheel will let him drive/park not on the spare tire and/or jack stand while the original is getting worked on.
reply
10 sats \ 1 reply \ @k00b OP 13h
The wheel is still drivable! It’s just aesthetically not great if you look close
reply
I did the same thing to my own 'new' used car
2019 Genesis G70, the nicest car I have ever owned.
I screwed up parking the car recently (aesthetic damage to tire and wheel/hubcap
I can relate with you 99 percent
reply
I feel for you. Curb rash is awful
reply