pull down to refresh

As an observer I would suggest most Chinese have accepted economic advancement is a priority over the supposed 'freedoms' of the western citizen.

It doesn't matter if it's a majority. We're not talking about the freedom to smoke pot. We're talking about not having to worry about getting sent to a concentration camp with no due process because your pastor committed a wrongthink. (Cue some retarded comparison to something the US did 100 years ago to one or two people under a Democrat presidency.)

Cuba, Iran, Venezuela and North Korea were not free, sovereign countries simply by virtue of not hosting a US military base. It doesn't look like the totalitarian dictorship is only a means to an end of opposing US influence. Rather, it seems they oppose the US only because they want to maintain their totalitarian dictorship.

And they gave up their freedom for nothing, because the US is still able to overpower them and the PRC militarily.

In any case, Taiwan hasn't accepted the argument and doesn't want to become a puppet state of the communist party. The communists have absolutely nothing of value to offer them. So if (when) the reds insist that "self-determination" means taking more clay, the US will make sure they end up in a new Nuremberg Trial.

What about ICE in USA today?
A New Zealand citizen who has been living as a legal resident in the US for decades has recently been incarcerated by ICE.

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/world/593630/locked-up-for-22-hours-a-day-what-life-is-like-for-new-zealander-everlee-wihongi-detained-in-ice-facility

NZ authorities are warning NZers not to travel to the US as the new visa rules mean you are required to show all social media posts for the last 5 years and can face immediate ban and forced removal from US with zero right of appeal. The USA is becoming a police state.

The assumed 'freedoms' and 'rights' westerners think make them superior to other nations are in fact largely only a result of centuries of resource hegemony and wealth extraction from third world nations.

China is showing a new model where you develop your economy on your terms- you do not dictate to trade partners what they should do and certainly do not invade them, assassinate their leaders or kidnap and threaten them with being bombed back to the stone ages.

China mercantile approach treats all other nations with respect for their sovereignty unlike the current US government and its approach for at least the last 50 years since it became the global superpower.

We in NZ refused to allow US nuclear warships into our ports so you cancelled our military alliance (ANZUS) and refused to enter a trade deal.
So we entered the first free trade deal between a 5 eyes western nation and have enjoyed huge economic benefit ever since.

Ultimately US power is a mix of soft and hard power and you are squandering the soft power under Trump, alienating those who were formerly closely aligned to your values- because your values has changed to that of a global bully and authoritarian despot.

I hope the US wakes up from its reactionary militaristic insanity before it is reduced to pariah state status...but maybe that is what is required before you will return to some sort of human decency?

reply
What about ICE in USA today?

The anecdote is even dumber than I expected. Yes, in order to avoid becoming Europe, and during wartime, the US adopted some of the tactics traditionally used by dictatorships, such as deporting people that came here illegally.

Ultimately US power is a mix of soft and hard power and you are squandering the soft power under Trump, alienating those who were formerly closely aligned to your values- because your values has changed to that of a global bully and authoritarian despot.

Nonsense. We were hated long before Trump started defending the border. The things you're calling "values" are patterns that were literally killing us. No country can survive the toxic combination of mass immigration and a nanny state. You would not tolerate mass immigration from Japan to your country.

In what sick world is Trump a despot and the IRGC are freedom fighters?

NZ authorities are warning NZers not to travel to the US as the new visa rules mean you are required to show all social media posts for the last 5 years and can face immediate ban and forced removal from US with zero right of appeal. The USA is becoming a police state.

They should tell you to migrate to California and start planning arson and assassinations with the other leftists. You won't get deported from here.

You don't actually believe Trump is a dictator. You're literally just butthurt that you lost the election because you wanted us to sell out Taiwan, because you have some kind of ethnic grudge and you're convinced that stomping on the best of Asia militarily is actually a way to stick it to the white man, even though the half-white US is a minority of the anti-communist coalition.

Don't worry, the US will be balkanized and irrelevant soon enough. It doesn't matter. Support from a third of the US is more than enough to topple the PRC. Again, the communists' fight is with God, not the US. They're doomed.

China is showing a new model where you develop your economy on your terms- you do not dictate to trade partners what they should do and certainly do not invade them, assassinate their leaders or kidnap and threaten them with being bombed back to the stone ages.

Oh boo-hoo. Poor "ser rico es malo" Maduro got kidnapped when he was just minding his own business not hurting anyone, trying to lift Venezuela out of poverty. Who is this argument for? There's no way you actually believe this.

reply

Look in the tech and administration departments of your universities.
Lots of Chinese faces.

Look in the tech departments of Apple, Google, Meta etc - predominantly Chinese faces.
Modern China celebrates and encourages engineering and technical learning skills.
Chinese kids love to learn science and engineering.

They now run the engine rooms of your top companies and learning centres.
You lost the trade war and the skills war.
Without those Chinese engineers and technicians you would not be able to produce anything anymore.

Your entire country has been infiltrated with Chinese in positions of power and without them you would collapse in a sad sprawling heap of ideocracy.

Even with them you are.

reply

Uh huh, racial resentment. I get it. I can relate.

What does that have to with your attempts at turning Taiwan communist? We don't care that you're better at math. That's not the reason we're going to war. We're going to war because you're the antagonistic dictatorial rogue state, not us.

reply

I am not seeking to turn Taiwan communist.
Neither is China or anyone else.
China today is not a communist nation despite the name of the ruling party.

China today is a mixed economy- a hybrid of state capitalism and free enterprise.
Much like most of the west was until the neoliberal era of the 1980 till present.
Ever since the neoliberal era of bankers and corporate dictating government policy the wests economic position has worsened.

If you do not understand this it is difficult to see how you could understand the absurdity of your claim that anyone is trying to make Taiwan become communist.

Taiwan has been a client state to the US, subservient to US military and monetary tributes ever since the 1950s.

Modern Taiwan has far more economic ties with mainland China than it does with the US.
The US is abandoning its support for Taiwan and reshoring microchip production to USA because it is clear that Taiwans future is much more closely aligned with mainland China than the declining US empire.

reply
China today is not a communist nation despite the name of the ruling party.

Really? Change the name then. Or change the party. How else do you expect me to read the situation when it's in the fucking name and the regime itself explicitly states a commitment to socialist ideology?

Taiwan is not a vassal of the US. That's pure projection because you want to make it a vassal of Beijing, which they don't want.

The US is abandoning its support for Taiwan

You wish. I know Trump and I can see what he's doing. Taiwan is a red line. If the government didn't support Taiwan then they'd have to be replaced immediately, then you really would be dealing with a rogue state and one that would be far more likely to abuse nuclear weapons than Trump. You're not getting Taiwan.

reply
reply

Might as well ask Trump to change the name of his party to Ideocracy Cronyism USA.

Not my place to tell people to change the names of their organisations...I am simply a neutral but interested observer from New Zealand.

Taiwan is militarily and monetarily subservient tribute state to the USA.
Just like S.Korea, Japan, Canada, Australasia, the UK, EU and many more.

Enjoy your global hegemony while it lasts.
Empires come and go.

reply

You have everything backwards. The USA is the tribute state to the Republic of China. Whatever we do with our military is entirely up to them.