pull down to refresh

There are plenty of helpful explainers that tell you that a reverse repo is the opposite of a repurchase agreement. Well great, that helps. Other places describe it like this: "the Fed sells a security to an eligible counterparty and simultaneously agrees to buy the security back the next day." No matter how many descriptions I read, I can't seem to wrap my head around it, so I called my cousin Mathilde and asked her to explain it to me.

What is the Overnight Reverse Repo Facility?

'Reverse repos are deposits private banks make at the Fed.'
'Deposits--like putting money in a bank?'
'Yes.'
'You're shitting me. All this time I've been breaking my brain to understand this and reverse repos are just deposits?'
'Pretty much.'
'What makes it reverse?'
'It's reverse because everything is always viewed from the Fed's perspective. The banks who make these deposits at the Fed have normal repos with the Fed.'
'Do I get repo when I put my money in the bank?'
'No, that's just a deposit.'
'But I thought you said reverse repos were deposits. I mean, I'm giving the bank cash and they're giving me a balance on their books and some interest. What's the difference?'
'The difference is that the Fed is giving the bank a bond as collateral. Only a moron would give the someone a bunch of money without any collateral.'
'I don't get any collateral from my bank...'
'...'
'But why does the Fed give their depositors collateral?'
'Because a reverse repo is a loan.'
'I thought you said it was a deposit.'
'Same thing.'
'So the Fed is taking out a bunch of loans every night? What do they do with the money?'
'Nothing. They just sit on it.'
'You're telling me that they were just sitting on hundred of billions of dollars every night. No big deal?'
'Yup.'
'Wow, well that sucks. Money is weird.'
'Government money is.'
'Can I ask you another question?'
'Sure.'
'What the hell does nighttime have to do with it?'
'Banks don't know how many deposits they will get on any given day. Maybe you won the lottery and you show up five minutes before closing to drop off your winnings. What do you think they do?'
'Isn't that what they have safes for? To keep money in?'
'Oh your poor wife.'
'What's the point of all the security guards and steel bars and thick walls? I've seen movies: there's always some kind of steel space hatch and you have to tunnel through ten-foot thick concrete to get in.'
'Use your imagination. Pretend your the bank where the lottery commission has accounts. Just before closing you get a call that the lotto winnings need to be paid out. What if you don't have the money?'
'Banks don't have the money?'
'Honey, banks never have the money.'
'What happens?'
'Well, it sounds like the lotto commission's bank needs loan and it just so happens that your bank has a surplus of cash...'
'You're joking!'
'No. Banks loan each other money at the end of the day. And they loan it to the Fed. One of the ways the Fed fucks with the system is by deciding what interest rate to offer when banks loan them money. You ever hear people talking about the Fed raising interest rates?'
'That's the interest rate?'
'One of them. See, if your bank loans money to the lotto commission's bank, maybe it doesn't pay it back on time or at all. That's risky. When they loan their money to the Fed it's risk-free--at least there's no worries that the Fed won't be able to print some more dollars for them. So private banks have to offer something better than whatever rate the Fed offers, other wise they won't be able to get any loans.'
'I still don't understand why the Fed wants money.'
If you're curious, Mathilde sent me these links too:
68 sats \ 1 reply \ @k00b 5 Mar
If rates are going up, why are RRPs going down?
Because banks have less money? Which would mean there are fewer loans being made in the economy, because banks can get good risk free rates not loaning their money into the economy, and those loans not taking place means less fractionalization of money?
When RRPs are up, does it mean tons of excess cash is sitting in banks, loans on loans on loans, without a productive use that would significantly exceed the risk-free rate?
reply
From what I read, rrp is getting lower because banks are getting more interest buying treasuries from the treasury (and other places).
The rate offered at the rrp facility is supposed to be the lowest rate on offer, setting the floor for others. Back in 2022 when the rrp spiked up to $2.7 trillion, the treasury and others were not offering a much better rate for their bonds, so banks didn't have much reason to put their money anywhere else.
Also, I think there is some duration risk in buying a low interest bond in 2022, whereas parking money at the rrp wasn't carrying that risk. I think a the fact that the rrp is getting drained is a sign that banks don't think treasuries at today's higher interest rates carry as much duration risk.
But I should probably ask Mathilde about this.
reply
ALL of this works only when the money is imaginary. Gold was a liability to their capacity to lie and cheat. The concepts behind Bitcoin make this impossible. No free rides - even for corporations (aka governments) that have a monopoly on guns and violence.
reply
@Scoresby let's say I loan money, buy bitcoin. Now my bank has to settle with exchange. How does the need for settlement with the btc exchange impact the bank compared to if I had spent the money in the fiat credit economy?
reply
I have a feeling the answer is not much. People may be buying a lot of btc, but I don't really think it is enough to shift balances meaningfully.
(I'm assuming you are getting at the idea that when you buy btc it ultimately has to settle and someone has to give you the btc, rather than just shifting dollars around in close proximity to the money printer.)
reply