pull down to refresh

110 sats \ 1 reply \ @jimmysong 10 Jun \ on: I'm Steve Lee, Spiral lead, AMA! AMA
Which covenants proposal, if any, do you prefer?
write
preview
this territory is moderated
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @moneyball OP 10 Jun
My view:
  • Generally an advocate for improving expressiveness including covenants
  • Slow & steady mindset. I don't believe there is some closing window of time we have to slip changes in.
  • In my mind there's a couple big differences between BIP54 and any covenants proposal. For one, BIP54 fixes consensus bugs and isn't adding new features. It should be able to more easily get consensus as long as the engineering is sound and well reviewed. Two, I'm not aware of 10 different competing proposals to fix those bugs. Whereas with covenants, there are a myriad of proposals all of which have pros and cons.
  • So I don't have a fav covenants proposal yet, but I do appreciate quite a bit of advancement in R&D over the past 4 years, so we have more proposals, each has matured, there's more mindshare on it. I'd like to see TXHASH mature a bit more. Perhaps it is the best solution?
reply