pull down to refresh

I was in Big Pink once. For some idiotic training session when I worked for the anchor tenant. My new boss had socialist leanings and my libertarian view was something he just couldn’t comprehend. I would soon be hired away and our discussions ended.
The U.S. Bancorp tower in downtown Portland is now half empty, with the bank, while leaving its name on the building, relocating most of its employees. “The property, once a premier address in the city, was afflicted with ‘vagrants sleeping in hallways of vacant office floors.’ They were ‘starting fires in stairwells, smoking fentanyl and defecating in common areas,’ according to papers the company filed in a lease-termination lawsuit,” wrote Peter Grant for the Wall Street Journal.
As reflected in the series Portlandia, the city is liberal and laid back. When I was there decades ago, homeless people were everywhere downtown. Eventually they took over the bank headquarters.
The building gets its nickname not from the political leanings of the city’s population but “because of its pink-hued Spanish granite and pink glazed glass.” The 42-story tower is up for sale at an asking price of about $70 million. “That is more than 80% below what the owners paid for it a decade ago,” Grant explained.
Pre-pandemic Portland attracted technology companies with the area’s natural beauty and low housing costs compared with Seattle and San Francisco.
The U.S. Bancorp Tower enjoyed growing rents and high occupancy levels. “The value of the 42-year-old tower kept rising as a series of institutional owners purchased and sold the property leading up to the 2015 purchase by Unico and the UBS fund.”
Tech tenant “Digital Trends signed a lease in 2013 and kept growing in the building, upgrading its space with a special kitchen, laundry room, bathroom and home theater for testing consumer products.” The company is now litigating to break its lease
But the pandemic, combined with the rampant homelessness and “the state’s botched experiment with drug decriminalization,” has led to a 35% vacancy in the downtown Portland office market. The city’s budget is dwindling due to the fall in property values. But, the city government has a tin ear and is piling on other taxes to house the homeless and provide pre-school for all.
Portland’s office market turmoil is not confined. The town’s residential market is also hurting. “A $600 million development including condos, office space and a Ritz-Carlton hotel that opened in 2023 is struggling. A lender is trying to take title to the property, partly because condo sales have been weak,” writes Grant.
In its court filing, Digital Trends said that Big Pink became a “cesspool of criminal activity and vandalism,” forcing it to vacate the property.
Natalie Fertig wrote for Politico last October, “This proudly liberal city has endured more than 100 days of often-violent protests, a fentanyl and homelessness crisis, a pandemic — and, in arguably the nation’s boldest progressive policy experiment in recent history — decriminalization of all drugs.”
Portland’s voters decided to throw out their entire government structure and replace it with a weaker mayor, expanded City Council and ranked choice voting.
The new mayor is considered pro-business. He’s likely too late for Big Pink.
Haven’t we seen this movie before, over and over and over again? The polity gets wealthy and the progressive/lefty/collectivist/Marxist/socialist/communist/murderers get voted in because people begin to think it is a good thing to share the wealth, of other people, of course. Then they say it is not the fault of the homeless that they are homeless drug addicts but our fault, so we should turn a blind eye to what they do. Then those people decide to take over properties and, still, they are given a blind eye as to what they are doing to other people’s property. Then the polity stops being wealthy because all the wealth moves to a more respectable place. Isn’t this just a picture of what locusts and virii do to their environments? They eat their environment up and spit it out, dead.
I have a really hard time seeing how the West Coast gets out of the mess their in. Their so ideologically locked in to this trajectory that even as it falls apart around them, they won't even entertain that they might have been wrong.
reply
I think it could happen quicker than you think. I think social views are like a Veblen good, and thus when their liberal views are no longer fashionable, the consensus can shift pretty quickly. In other words, few of these ideologues are true believers, and once these beliefs no longer signal virtue they'll quickly switch to different beliefs.
reply
I hope that's right. It just doesn't fit with my experience of these people. I may not live on the West Coast, but most of my social circle does.
I could imagine them allowing for some realities eventually, but not giving up the premises that generated the errors. Eventually, there will be a generational shift in values, I suppose.
reply
From everything I read, it looks like gen Z is moving to a more “conservative” way of thinking.
I think the pendulum swings more on a time scale than a generational scale. Also, as people get older they seem to get more “conservative”, don’t they?
reply
as people get older they seem to get more “conservative”, don’t they?
Normally, I think, but I'm not sure it holds out there.
reply
I just noticed it in people around me. The older they are, sometimes, the more conservative they get. I have some neighbors in their 70s and 80s that seem pretty darn conservative.
Looking at the ideologies as Veblen goods is a new approach to me. It seems that a lot of the people taking these views are motivated more by envy than status. Although, I can see the point of your argument that if it suddenly becomes an anti-Veblen good things would change quickly. I just wonder if this approach has ever been tried. How fast would the change be, do you think?
reply
What they want to do to the rest of the country is happening to them first! They are trying to destroy the economy and the civilization to be able to build their progressive/lefty/collectivist/Marxist/socialist/communist/murderers’ utopia. Many of us know it has never happened and never will happen with progressive/lefty/collectivist/Marxist/socialist/communist/murderers in charge of the state. We have seen it too many times already. What is most disgusting is that even in China, slavery is making a big comeback under this utopian dream that they have in store for everyone.
reply
I think the people will have to live with their choices until the choices hurt. Then, hurt some more until they change their choices. I guess a lot of people only learn the hard way.
reply
I grew up in Seattle and spent a lot of time up and down the Pacific NW coast (Portland, Vancouver, BC)...it's a funny place politically. The last 40 years of socialist politics came out of a more liberty-focused mindset. Washington had some of the best homeschooling laws of all the states, and still doesn't have an income tax (although they are trying to change that). It used to value freedom.
Their response to the pandemic was so strong, I ended up moving. This is something I never thought I would do. The northwest is one of the mist beautiful places on earth and the climate is pretty near perfect (rain is good for you).
I'm hopeful things will get less bonkers, but it may be a long, unpleasant road. Till then, I'm far from home.
reply
Yes, it seems that a lot of places have been overtaken by the progressive/lefty/collectivist/Marxist/socialist/communist/murderers. They seem to ruin even the best of places by doing what they do. My only question is why do people put up with it? The only reason I can think of is envy or power lust. However, envy and power lust are the worst ways to run the state.
reply
my childhood (in a conservative family in the NW) was an exercise in listening to adults complain about politics.
when I got older, I got to know a lot of people who were quite happy with the way politics in the NW were going. I don't think they were power-hungry people. More like they are operating with wildly different values. Freedom is not as important to such a world view as fairness or equality. Seeking power for yourself is somewhat hard to hide from yourself, but seeking power on behalf of others, to do good for others...this is limitless and never feels bad. This is how we get such messed up systems.
reply
Seeking power for yourself is somewhat hard to hide from yourself, but seeking power on behalf of others, to do good for others...this is limitless and never feels bad.
G.K. Chesterton: Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron’s cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.
Another way to say this is: The road to hell is paved with good intentions. People never see themselves as evil, do they? It is always the other guy doing the bad news stuff.
reply
So many of my thoughts Chesterton thought before me.
reply
I have heard that there is nothing new under the sun! That was apparently a quote from about 4,000 years ago.