Israel has begun its attack on Iran:
Israel said it struck dozens of targets across Iran aiming to cripple Tehran’s nuclear program, pushing the region toward a new conflict with uncertain consequences.
The U.S. officially denies having any part in the attack, but the attack would not be possible without the extensive support that the U.S. has provided to Israel for decades. The Trump administration has claimed that it didn’t want Israel to attack now, but clearly they did nothing to stop it from happening. U.S. forces may not be directly involved in the current operation, but there is no question that Trump owns this outcome thanks to his bankrupt Iran policy and his reflexive backing for the Israeli government.
Israel’s bombing campaign is likely to be a prolonged one. We can expect Iran’s response to be swift and intense, and Iran has enough missiles that it will likely be able to overwhelm Israeli defenses and inflict serious damage. Steve Witkoff reportedly told a gathering of Senate Republicans this week that Iranian retaliation could result in a “mass casualty” event. That is what Netanyahu has chosen to bring on his own country through his reckless aggression and his desire to cling to power.
As I said earlier, this is criminal aggression. It is also simply deranged. The Israeli government claims that it is acting “preemptively,” but there is no imminent threat to preempt. Israel is trampling on international law and violating Iranian sovereignty in clear violation of the U.N. Charter. Netanyahu has reconfirmed that his government is one of the principal threats to regional peace and stability.
The idea that the threat of an Israeli attack was some sort of ruse to improve the U.S. negotiating position was too clever by half. Sometimes an insane threat to attack another country is just an insane threat to attack another country. It is hard to see how there can be a negotiating process between the U.S. and Iran while this is going on. We have to assume that this was one of the real reasons why Netanyahu chose to attack now. The negotiations weren’t going anywhere thanks to Trump’s maximalism, but Netanyahu didn’t want to take the chance there might be a diplomatic breakthrough.
In addition to the terrible crimes committed against the people of Gaza on his orders, the devastation of Lebanon, and the bombing of Syria, Netanyahu is responsible for initiating hostilities against yet another country. Iranian and Israeli civilians will pay the price for Netanyahu’s latest criminal actions. All of the evils that follow will be on his head.
As if this weren’t bad enough, Israel’s attacks won’t even set back Iran’s nuclear program very much. Arms control expert Ankit Panda commented earlier tonight:
Knowing what I know, I don't see these strikes meaningfully putting Iran's program back (I suppose you can quibble about what meaningful constitutes for Netanyahu). Iran will strike back and odds of a political choice to leave the NPT/take other steps have gone up.
Attacking Iran’s nuclear facilities has always been a bad gamble. It is unnecessary, it won’t “work” the way that the hawks claim it will, and it will lead to worse outcomes. Netanyahu is going to get a lot of people killed for no good reason for his own selfish ends, and everyone else will be left worse off than before.
The U.N. Security Council ought to condemn Israel’s acts of aggression, but we know that Trump will continue to shield Israel’s war criminal leadership and the U.S. would veto any censure resolution. The U.S. ought to cut off all weapons supplies to a client government that has just illegally attacked another state, but we know Trump and Rubio will keep those weapons flowing. Netanyahu may have decided to launch this attack unilaterally, but he did so because he knew that the U.S. would back him every step of the way. The Israeli government is guilty of carrying out the attack, but the U.S. enabled all of it.
Insanity is probably just a polite way to say criminally insane. Is this one country too far? Will DJT back this move as he has backed every other criminal activity by Israel? When will the world wake up to the fact that the Israelis are committing the very crimes they claim to have been victims of in the past? And, finally, when does the rest of the world say, ”NO MORE!!” to that whole criminal country? They have wrung my sympathy dry.