pull down to refresh

This is what Bitcoin has become:
Full blocks, but blocks full of
Whose only purpose is the "Uncommon Goods" memecoin
Entire blocks are the same op_return transaction, with the same addresses over and over
Or consolidations of more 'memecoins'
The number of 'real' transactions, economic transactions, with an economic purpose, is effectively extremely small.
And "this" is what most transactions look like
Pages and Pages and Pages of BRC20 tokens ('minted' in Witness script)
OR the transactions represent ways of stuffing 'data' in order to speculate on playing cards, 'collectible' images, or NFTs
This is not what Bitcoin was supposed to be about.
The number of economic transactions, although potentially 'hidden' under Lightning, is very very small and incredibly minuscule relative to real-world demand.
Meanwhile, there is a massive, significant government-led clampdown on digital privacy
With no easy solutions or "give and take" with governments that want NO 'give and take'... they want total control over money and your privacy.

Meanwhile Nostr, Bitcoin's social media for all practical purposes, is filled with Number-Go-Up feel-good bullshit.
Or conspiracy-theories that have nothing to do with Bitcoin
What good is Bitcoin if no-one is using it???
If blocks are full of junk (worthless NFTs and Memecoins) negligible fees, with very limited real-world monetary usage for actual goods and services...
Even the Monero Boys (and I am not a fan of Monero) speak the truth now and then:
"Presenting Bitcoin to outsiders as an NGU-driven get‑rich‑quick scheme invited the worst of society inside. Now deal with the consequences, you’ll have to live with your own poison. You will never separate money from state because this choices [sic] and behavior!
Fake freedom figthers [sic] all postures, no principles.
He is right, we have invited some of the worst, most speculative and desperate people to Bitcoin... They don't transact, they don't hold their own keys or run a node, all they care about is 'speculation'.
Bitcoiners talk of "challenging the BIS" (bank of international settlements), replacing the Fed, or even pressuring the IMF...
But these things aren't serious if the actual amount of Bitcoin USE is so small.
There is a lot of talk, a lot of noise... but the Memepool doesn't lie.
~5 minutes after the last block... ALL the entire world's on-chain Bitcoin transactions, awaiting confirmation, fit within the non-green parts.
Some Starbucks coffee-lines are longer than this...
How is that going to challenge the BIS or IMF or do anything to improve money?
Bitcoin isn't destined to succeed. Apathy, laziness, greed, or successful state-clampdowns can and will ruin Bitcoin under certain circumstances.
In short, Nostr is full of sandwhich pictures
But it's light on real Bitcoin usage and it shows.
The truth will come to light in the end.
100 sats \ 1 reply \ @fiatbad 6h
I've made a lot of big-blocker arguments on SN in the past. I always have to preface by saying, I am NOT a big-blocker and I own zero B-cash or crypto of any kind outside of Bitcoin.
But goddamm if Roger Ver didn't make some good points. His book "Hijacking Bitcoin" changed my view on a lot of things. Not enough to join his cause.... but enough to question the honey-badger kinds of narratives pushed around here.
I can't help but think that Core was hijacked, exactly how he describes, in order to ensure that Bitcoin can only be used as a SoV, and never as a MoE. The "Freedom Money" ethos has slowly died out, and been replaced by bullshit narratives about how MoE will "happen eventually, just not now".
I'm still not a big-blocker, because I also understand the reasons why Roger is wrong. But dammit, I'm incredibly disappointed at the current state of Bitcoin... especially the human element of it...
OP, your post is really good. Thanks for making it.
reply
Thank you.
In my humble opinion, the problems in Bitcoin today aren't 'technical'... they are cultural, social, and educational. I also own no crypto outside of Bitcoin, and echo the same things about 'big blocks'...
I haven't read 'Hijacking Bitcoin' (I'll check it out) and while I understand the reasons behind 'small blocks' I also feel we have lost our way somehow. Bitcoin the token is obviously quite valuable... but Bitcoin the network blockspace is almost worthless and there is a tone-deafness in the 'community' that doesn't sit right with me.
The "Freedom Money" ethos has slowly died out, and been replaced by bullshit narratives
I see this hardcore on Nostr and it is really just... sad. People who obviously should and do know better... want to pretend that all is right in Kansas when it is NOT. We are losing the war for 'better money' that's reasonably private and actually used and the head-in-the-sand imho doesn't help things.
But dammit, I'm incredibly disappointed at the current state of Bitcoin... especially the human element of it...
I am too. We could have a reasonable MoE and way more Bitcoin usage... but people just don't care. They'll LARP and tell you how great "freedom money" is but it's all BS when the mempool is empty.
If Bitcoin fails the laziness, apathy, greed, and negligence will be at fault... but you won't hear that on Nostr. The truth will come out eventually.
reply
The war for Freedom, for Better Money, for separation of Money and State... due to Apathy, Laziness, Greed, and a strong government clamp-down on Privacy and Sovereignty...
Is being Lost.
Sometimes the Good Guys lose the war and we are losing.
reply
This is the true Bitcoin battle
reply
15 sats \ 1 reply \ @3a42879d5f 12h
He is right, we have invited some of the worst, most speculative and desperate people to Bitcoin... They don't transact, they don't hold their own keys or run a node, all they care about is 'speculation'.
People doing things you don't like is part of freedom.
reply
It's not 'what I don't like'. It's the state of the network and it is not growing in a healthy fashion that incorporates a healthy, vibrant fee market.
reply
15 sats \ 1 reply \ @3a42879d5f 12h
What's like, the point of this post? Are NFTs and memecoins somehow restricting you from using Bitcoin? Are you incapable of spending more than 1sat on a transaction fee to get your transaction higher priority and included in a block? Gimme a break, the tx fees have been 1000s of times higher what they are right now. The fees right now are a blessing.
reply
Are NFTs and memecoins somehow restricting you from using Bitcoin?
No they're not. But that's not the point of the article/post.
The fees right now are a blessing.
No they're not. The anemic fees are a sign that no-one is using Bitcoin and the network is not growing healthy.
reply
You can't shove freedom down people's throats. Those who deserve it use Bitcoin privately on L2 Lightning and Liquid networks. L1 is easily traced and only suitable as an aggregate settlement level for L2s. DEX trading volumes are also going up. BIS are locking themselves out from seeing our flows. They were never expected to do down without a fight.
reply
I have used Lightning in many different places, in person and online in several different countries.
The 'next generations' in my opinion are not learning the lessons of history, they are not leaning their Bitcoin history, there is too much emphasis on 'corporate treasuries' and not enough emphasis on soverignity, self-custody, and Bitcoin usership.
We are not going to 'change the world' by watching Bitcoin's ticker go up and down while a few companies buy up a ton of Bitcoin.
There needs to be, eventually, a vibrant fee market to offset the declining subsidy - that fact is on a timer and while we have time we don't have forever.
This is a war for better and more monetary freedom, and we are losing it.
reply
121 sats \ 0 replies \ @fiatbad 6h
This is a war for better and more monetary freedom, and we are losing it.
"Naw bro, you don't understand. NGU happens first, then MoE can happen. It costs too much taxes to spend mah Bitcoin... just use dollars. Also, spend the weak money first." /s
(I completely agree with you)
reply
It's just a bunch of data entered into a paid transaction. This mound of data only becomes something if you organize it correctly. Trying to filter this is introducing an element of censorship that Bitcoin doesn't have.
Regarding Nostr and all this chaos you promoted in your warning post, I can only think that this is how decentralization should be: free.
reply
I think Shinobi makes the point I'm trying to make so much better
reply
reply
I agree with much of what Shinobi says he speaks his mind and says what he thinks even if it's unpopular
reply
I already noticed the mempool was acting weird, and this isn't the way I want to see things go. Is it possible to know, in percentages, what kind of UTXO belongs to what?
reply
Click on 'data' on mempool.space. The 'highlighted' stuff is data-carrying 99% of which is memecoins and NFTs.
Most blocks are full of it. And after the 'next block' is mined there are literally no on-chain transactions waiting in the mempool across the entire world's economies.
reply
bitcoin is like a honey-badger. he doesn't give a damn.
reply
Now's a good time to open some lightning channels I'd guess!
What are routing fees on Lightning currently? It could be a good time to earn some routing profits, since re-establishing drained channels will be cheap.
reply