pull down to refresh

there's a common joke among mathematicians, that as your mathematical mind develops, so does your arithmetic computer atrophy.

I think it's quite understandable; as a mind becomes aware of more useful kinds of numbers[1], and more kinds of patterns[2] that enable computational tricks, there is a temptation to explore new possibilities rather than charge forth along whichever computational path was learned at a younger age.

I honestly don't think that the capability of reckoning accurately and rapidly in decimal base is worth retaining at grade-school levels. Even if you're e.g. checking over a bill at a restaurant, the important tasks are probably remembering who ordered what and comparing the billed prices to the listed ones, rather than verifying that their point-of-sale performed arithmetic correctly.

  1. most useful kinds are ideals or fields; the most familiar ideals are multiples of any prime, while e.g. "all ratios with a power of two in the denominator" is a field

  2. consider the trick of doubling and shifting the decimal point left, as a shortcut for multiplying dividing by five; it's only the first in an infinite series of similar tricks, for multiplying dividing by powers of five

haha Von Neumann must have truly been an alien then!

reply

well some people specifically practice lightning calculation; similarly to how some kid who grew up playing catch might keep on practicing with friends or the next generation, despite not needing the affordance.

I think lightning calculation has always had a bit of an "autistic savant" reputation, because it is so sterile when compared to even things like playing chess or solving a Rubik's Cube.

reply