pull down to refresh

This article is a one long case of "we should require everyone to prove that they aren't crazy like my mom."
But even worse, it's a case that the ultimate responsibility for everyone lies with the state. It is crazy to me that anyone buys this argument.
By my third year of home-schooling — in 1994, when I was 12 — Mom’s project of turning me back into an infant was nearly complete.
Ever since she’d pulled me out of school, she had been applying lighteners and hydrogen peroxide to restore my brownish hair to the bright blonde of its baby color. After reading that a crawling phase might help an infant develop fine motor control, she determined that, even at age 12, it might not be too late for me to crawl my way to better handwriting.
She had me crawl whenever I was at home, which was most of the time. Mom home schooled me between fourth and eighth grades, and even today, as a parent who has come to see plainly how damaging those years were, I know that she believed that her choice was in my best interest.
It was the lack of state oversight or standards that allowed our situation. It was the laws that failed me. Today, as home-schooling numbers continue to surge, similar laws fail to protect millions of kids.
Not once, in the four and a half years I spent at home, did anyone from the state come to assess what sort of education I was receiving, or even just to check on me.
We homeschool our kids and my wife's parents provide us with a steady stream of "concerns" that come from this sort of mindset.
Those who oppose regulation claim that such cases are rare, and they rightfully argue that educational neglect and abuse happen at school as well. But we’ve created a system in which it’s impossible to know how common home-schooling abuse might actually be.
This may be the most troubling thing that plagues modern governments: they think there is no risk in the state "knowing" things about its populace.
this territory is moderated
she had been applying lighteners and hydrogen peroxide to restore my brownish hair to the bright blonde of its baby color
blind eye to public schools turning kids into pink haired gender goblins
reply
great observation. Her mom, it transported to today, would probably be exactly one of those.
reply
Time is a flat circle, home-schoolers used to be the nutters, now state-schoolers are the nutters
edit: unfortunately one family my kids play with think the earth is flat because they interpret the bible as saying the sky is a firmament... but still less nutty than the shit that comes out of their public school peers
reply
Hmm, I move in pretty conservative Christian circles, including many home schoolers, but I haven't yet met an unironic flat earther
reply
Their mother is one of the genuinely nicest and most responsible people we know, and had a... suffice it to say challenging... childhood of her own.
I don't think the Dad believes in a flat earth, but also is choosing his battles, too busy working his ass off so she can stay home and still keep their heads above water financially.
At least their spectrum of playmates has taught my kids to nod politely moreso than I ever would have 😂
reply
true, it's hard to know exactly how much home-school abuse there is.
...but COMPARED TO THE VERY KNOWN, VERY OBVIOUS ABUSE IN PUBLIC SCHOOL?!
Get a grip.
reply
Meh, typical fare for an entertainment rag like the New York Times. It's common for their small minded readership to think that one person's experiences equates to everyone's experiences1

Footnotes

  1. So long as that one person's experiences are consistent with liberal orthodoxy and calls for more state intervention to routinize and sanitize everyone's life
reply
Also, homeschooling 30 years ago is not the same as homeschooling now.
Don’t be a Boomer and assume things are the same as when you experienced them back in nineteen-clickety-clack.
reply
102 sats \ 0 replies \ @OT 10h
Where I live in Australia there's is a "moderator" that comes around to registered homeschooling families. This is the states mechanism to stop extreme cases like this.
We're just starting out homeschooling but I'm sure we'll get a lot of this common backlash as we go.
reply