pull down to refresh

84 sats \ 2069 boost \ 10 comments \ @Bell_curve 4h AskSN
zaps forwarded to @Undisciplined (10%) @siggy47 (10%)

Michael Malice’s excellent anthology, The Anarchist’s Handbook, includes an essay by John Hasnas, a professor of law and business at Georgetown.

He opens his essay with a simple quiz:

On the basis of your personal understanding of the meaning of this sentence (not your knowledge of Constitutional law), please indicate whether you believe the following sentences to be true or false.

  1. In time of war, a federal statute may be passed prohibiting citizens from revealing military secrets to the enemy.
  2. The President can issue an executive order prohibiting public criticism of his administration.
  3. Congress may pass a law prohibiting museums from exhibiting photographs and paintings depicting homosexual activity.
  4. A federal statute can be passed prohibiting a citizen from falsely shouting “fire” in a crowded theater.
  5. Congress may pass a law prohibiting dancing to rock and roll music
  6. The Internal Revenue Service may issue a regulation prohibiting the publication of a book explaining how to cheat on your taxes and get away with it.
  7. Congress may pass a statute prohibiting flag burning.

https://www.law.georgetown.edu/faculty/john-hasnas/

Hasnas successfully argues that human law (versus the laws of nature) are necessarily ambiguous and subject to interpretation, which interpretations will not only be biased by the values and prejudices of the interpreter but almost wholly determined by them.

I will display the correct answers in 24 hours or whenever @siggy47 reminds me

I scored 2 out of 7

#1429702

reply

Based on the wording, I think they are all true.

They might not withstand a legal challenge but those groups can do those kinds of things.

reply

Right. Congress has passed many laws that have been declared unconstitutional. Now that the constitution is more or less meaningless, the title is apt.

reply

True for all 7 questions? got it

reply
47 sats \ 2 replies \ @m0wer 3h

I don't know what the "correct' answer is. But should be "no" to all.

reply

your answer is False for all 7 questions?

reply
11 sats \ 0 replies \ @m0wer 1h

The "law" probably makes all of those true.

I'm my opinion, no one should have those powers.

reply
11 sats \ 1 reply \ @siggy47 fwd 3h

@remindme in 24 hours

reply

I need a lawyer to take this stupid quiz

reply

The only rule we have right now is the golden rule, who has the gold makes the rules.

reply