pull down to refresh

If your post is about what created American wealth, then let’s not play games: slavery was part of that wealth creation story. Not just the invisible hand.

no it wasn't, idiot. (this is a common, leftist myth... start learning by reading my follow-along review of Beckert -- one of said myth propagators -- book: #1416318).

also, to your substantive question: no, my post is about the industrial revolution. Which happened in BRITAIN, and to which the U.S. is just an uninteresting second/third act.

reply

You’re acting like slavery was irrelevant to industrialization. It wasn’t.

Slave labor produced ~12–13% of U.S. GDP at its peak, which is equivalent to $3.5–4T/year today.

And ~75% of global cotton, which was the core input of British industry, came from U.S. slave plantations.

That’s not a side note. That’s the supply chain.

reply

It was irrelevant to industrialization, and in no way correspondent to that sort of modern figures #1422896

The only thing interesting about slavery is its abolishing

reply

If slavery was irrelevant, why did British industry depend so heavily on slave-grown cotton?

Are you saying CPI is flawed, or that slavery didn’t matter? Those are different claims.

If cotton was the main input for British textiles, and slaves produced the cotton, where does “irrelevant” come from?

reply

It didn't... It was immaterial. Take away slavery, and British industrial revolution would have happened just as well.

And no, you're the one invoking some modern-day equivalent number. Don't do that

reply

So your claim is: take away slave-grown cotton from the core textile industry, and nothing materially changes?

reply

yes.

What's so hard/objectionable/unacceptable about this? Slavery, as abhorrent an institution it is from our modern pow -- having been present absolutely everywhere in human history -- was economically inefficient, upheld by communal subsidies, and played an altogether minor (read: none) role in bring about the rich, modern world

reply

And it wasn’t just cotton, slaves produced tobacco, sugar, rice, indigo. If all of that disappears, what replaces those outputs in your model?