What do you call this sequence?
- Alvin Brown was confirmed by the Senate to serve on the NTSB through the end of 2026.
- By law, an NTSB member is not supposed to be removable at will. There has to be cause, like serious misconduct or failure to do the job.
- Brown says he was removed anyway, and no reason was given.
- Brown is Black. The other board members at the time were white.
- Brown was the only Democrat Trump removed.
- But the filing says party alone does not explain it, because other white Democrats on the board were left in place.
- In fact, the filing says Trump could have replaced a different Democrat’s seat instead, but did not.
- The filing says this fits a broader pattern:
approximately 75 percent of Black federal officials leading multimember agencies have been removed from office
vs approximately 27 percent of white federal officials on multimember agencies. - It points to another example too: Gen. Charles Q. Brown Jr., who is Black, was removed as Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and replaced by a white officer who did not meet the usual statutory qualification and could serve only because Trump waived it.
- Then Trump nominated John DeLeeuw to Brown’s seat, and DeLeeuw was sworn in and began serving in that role.
- Brown is now using a legal action that basically asks: what gives this new person the lawful right to hold that office at all?
If all of that is true, then this is not just a dispute over whether one firing was legal.
It is whether Brown was singled out, and whether the replacement was how that decision was made to stick.