pull down to refresh

We're a math-traumatized people, Jo Boaler says (although she uses the British locution “maths-traumatized”). It’s a belief she sees confirmed in everything from students crying over long division to MRIs that reveal young brains reacting to numbers as if they were snakes or spiders. And it’s something she hears just as clearly in the resignation of that common refrain: “I am not a math person.”

Boaler, a professor at the Graduate School of Education, sees math altogether differently — as a subject of beauty and creativity in which any student can thrive. Indeed, her Britishness only partly explains why she prefers “maths.” The plural, she says, is more apt for mathematics’ depth and variety. “Math” strikes her as narrow and constricted. “Maths is so much more than that,” she says.

It’s easy, though, for her to evoke math anxieties in listeners, often with little more than an elementary school worksheet. The sight of a three-minute test dense with 50 multiplication problems reliably stirs nervous memories in ways it’s hard to imagine an elementary reading assignment doing.

“I just spoke to a whole incoming group of freshmen last week at Stanford,” Boaler said in the fall. “I put this on the screen and the whole room broke out: ‘Blah, isn’t this terrible?’ ”

...read more at stanfordmag.org

I really dunno about this. I only skimmed the article, but I'm skeptical of any attempts to take drilling out of mathematical education. It would be like taking long practice sessions out of musical education. You can't build the fluency necessary for higher level abstract concepts if you don't have the foundations secure.

IMO, the more we go away from drilling, the poorer US math education will become. I'm a big believer in the idea that mimicry comes before understanding. You need to be able to do the long division algorithm by rote before you really start to build an understanding for it.

I understand the dread students feel, and how it makes them feel like "they're not math people." I think the answer isn't to stop drills. It's to allow students to progress at their own pace without fear of failure.

Again, it's a lot like music. We need to acknowledge some are more talented than others and can pick it up faster, but anyone can play an instrument beautifully, if they take their time and have the right mindset.

To me, the indictment is more on one-size-fits-all, age-cohort-based education, than it is about drilling math.

reply