Last Sunday, my wife decided she wanted to watch "The Light Between Oceans" (2016). Knowing it was going to be a real tearjerker, I decided to pour myself a nice glass of red wine to soften the blow.
I wasn't wrong. The film takes us to a remote Australian island after World War I, where a lighthouse keeper and his wife face the tragedy of not being able to have children.
The plot kicks off with a bang when a boat washes ashore with a dead man and a live baby. Instead of reporting it, they decide to keep the child.
From there, the film becomes a profound exploration of guilt and morality. Drawing on my Christian perspective, I came up with these ideas that fit perfectly (or at least they did for me):
- The Temptation of Eden: The island functions as that private paradise where the couple bites the forbidden apple of stolen happiness, justifying their actions under the guise of grief.
- The weight of conscience: The lighthouse, meant to guide the lost, becomes the stage for a slow psychological torture. In the end, guilt completely consumes the protagonist, demonstrating that a life cannot be built on a lie.
- Doing the right thing comes at a price: The film's core message harshly highlights that we must do the right thing, even when the truth destroys our world and brings unbearable pain.
Visually, it's stunning, and the performances are powerful. In the end, my wife was sobbing uncontrollably. I, of course, only shed a single, very subtle tear... you know, just to keep up appearances and act tough, but the truth is, it touches your heart.
A mature drama that leaves you pondering honesty, punishment, and forgiveness. Ideal for watching with a partner and a good glass of wine.
Rating: 8/10