I'm open to anything tbh. We are getting a lot more open source contributions, and if I can review better I can respect the work more.
Overall having comments in a not-github way has a noticeable increase in difficulty for the general-coding public.
It's worth trying to do things more openly/in-github when possible (IMO). Github is quite opinionated though and does take time to adapt workflow to the github-way.
There are a bunch of branch protection rules that can be combined depending on how much you want to block merging before the review is "finished".
reply