The "Challenge to Orthodoxy" theory draws a parallel between Martin Luther's 95 Theses and Satoshi Nakamoto's Bitcoin whitepaper, both of which were released on October 31st. The significance here lies in the act of challenging a centralized authority, as well as the methods employed to disseminate the revolutionary ideas.
  1. Central Authority: Luther aimed to reform the Catholic Church, a dominant centralized religious authority. Satoshi targeted centralized financial systems, namely central banks and financial institutions.
  2. Disintermediation: Both aimed to remove middlemen from essential human activities—Luther in the context of spirituality and divine grace, and Satoshi in the context of financial transactions.
  3. Public Discourse: Luther's theses were nailed to the church door, a public forum of sorts, and rapidly spread thanks to the printing press. Satoshi used a mailing list to share the whitepaper, leveraging the Internet to engage with the public directly.
  4. Democratic Access: Both innovations intended to democratize access to essential services. Luther's reformation made it possible for commoners to have a direct relationship with God without the mediation of priests. Satoshi's blockchain technology aims to make financial transactions possible without the need for banks or payment processors.
  5. Subversion of Existing Systems: Luther questioned the Church’s sale of indulgences, a significant revenue source. Satoshi's introduction of Bitcoin threatened the foundational aspects of modern banking, including the printing of money and the necessity of financial intermediaries.
  6. Date Significance: If the date was intentionally chosen to mirror that of the 95 Theses, it might have been a symbolic call-to-arms against modern, centralized financial systems, much like Luther's theses were against the Catholic Church.
  7. Global Impact: Both acts have had a profound global impact. The Reformation led to the creation of Protestant denominations and changed the course of Western history. Bitcoin and the technologies it spawned are redefining how we think about money and decentralized systems.
By releasing the Bitcoin whitepaper on the same date as Luther's 95 Theses, Satoshi might have been signaling the revolutionary potential of his creation, aiming to instigate a reformation of modern finance.