pull down to refresh
0 sats \ 6 replies \ @supertestnet 16 Jan freebie \ parent \ on: Can we make 2-of-3 Multisigs a better user experience? bitcoin
"move to X then Y" doesn't sound like a dealbreaker for any reasonable person
Is your grandmother unreasonable?
If so, consider talking some sense into her
To be clear, this is not a question of reasonableness or security. You can set up a perfectly secure multisig wallet with the technology we have today.
This is purely about the user experience, and making it intuitive for a new person to understand. Bitcoin is complicated enough as it is, but it can be explained in extremely simple terms:
Your funds are stored at an address, which is a location on the Internet no different than the address that identifies the location of your house.
Your funds at the address are controlled by keys. And a key is represented by 12 words (or 24 if you choose).
In a single sig, you need only one key to unlock and move funds, but in a multisig, you can set it up so that you need 2 of 3 different keys. This provides redundancy in case you lose one.
That’s it. And the user experience should match that, at least for the average consumer.
Cold storage is terrifying for most people, but it doesn’t need to be. And there’s no reason why people should be introduced to Bitcoin through exchanges, and only later taught to move the funds to cold storage.
You don’t truly learn about Bitcoin until you take it into your possession, and we should develop an outstanding user experience that matches that behavior.
Again, this isn’t about what’s reasonable to ask someone to do. The burden is on us to create the most beautiful, simplistic, and dare I say magical user experience that could possibly exist. Technology should be like magic, and Bitcoin should be no different.
reply
You don’t truly learn about Bitcoin until you take it into your possession, and we should develop an outstanding user experience that matches that behavior.
And "move to X then Y" is not sufficiently magical and outstanding in your opinion?
Things might improve a bit if coinbase supported "bare" multisig addresses
That would eliminate the middle step, though I still maintain that if your grandma is "scared" of a middle step then she is not being reasonable. Consider calmly and rationally explaining to her why the middle step is there ("coinbase doesn't support this address type" -- see? it takes 6 words) rather than acting as if she is incapable of doing anything other than a one click experience, or incapable of overcoming irrational fears
The burden is on us to create the most beautiful, simplistic, and dare I say magical user experience that could possibly exist
No, that is an unnecessary and overburdensome task. No one needs an experience that perfect because good enough is good enough, and since no one needs that perfect experience, no one needs to build it.