28 sats \ 5 replies \ @elvismercury 27 Jan \ parent \ on: Do you supplement? What supplements do you take? health
Both.
I go out of my way to get a high w-3 balance in my diet. Do you think I might be overlooking something?
reply
If you're making an effort you're probably doing pretty well.
Last I checked into this in any depth, there was a massive amount of disagreement over what w-3 levels should be, esp given current w-6 levels, esp given nutrient leaching due to industrial food production (cmp w-3 content in game vs industrial meat, for instance), esp given other pro-inflammatory covariates of modern industrialized lifestyles. Nutrition science is nearly the most thankless of all the quasi-sciences, so I certainly don't know the truth.
I just thought of this, but: are you making an exception to veganism wrt w-3 supplementation, or do you get some vegetable source of it? I'd be curious what that is, if the latter. That might be a thing to consider making an exception over, since my vague sense from having looked into this deeply twenty years ago is that vegetable versions would be drastically sub-optimal; but again, talking 65% out of my ass here.
reply
The highest w-3 foods are flax and chia seeds. Some other nuts and seeds have really good w-3/w-6 ratios.
My understanding is that the ratio is most important, but like you say it's hard to pin that down very accurately. The most common number I see is 1:4, but I recall seeing 1:1.6. Since my diet is not very inflammatory I'm ok with targeting the 1:4.
You're right that plant sources are sub-optimal, but our bodies are capable of converting between the different forms of w-3. With the quantity of w-3 I consume, I'm pretty sure I'm producing sufficient levels of those particular forms.
reply
Ah, it's coming back to me. When I left the discussion, the hot topic was how much of the plant-based w-3 really could be converted, with opinions varying drastically and the research being called into question / accused of being inapplicable for assorted reasons. (One of the reasons was that one camp viewed this not as a fixed conversion rate, but as dynamic and adaptive.)
Not to reignite controversy, but I'm curious if you feel anything from it? It's remarkable to me how much I do feel the psychotropic effects of smallish amounts of w-3 in concentrated fish-oil form. It's possible it's placebo, but I don't get the feeling from actual fatty fish, which is interesting. But it's strong enough for me that I take it in the evening to calm down and get ready for bed. Doesn't work w/ flaxseed oil, either. I'm quite sensitive to mind-altering substances, though.
reply
if you feel anything from it?
I was taking fish oil recently. We had been giving it to our old dog to ease her joint pain. After she died, I took the rest of it. I wouldn't say I noticed anything, though.
reply