Did anyone watch Masters of the Air? I only watched the first episode but I don't think it's even close to being as good as Band of Brothers or The Pacific. The conversations feel forced as if everyone is trying to one-up each other in how cool they are. Maybe I had too high expectations or it gets better in the following episodes.
why do you have time to watch shows. 👀
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @ek 21 Feb
why not 👀
reply
What is it about war dramas that interests you? I can think of many reasons but I’m curious if you’ve thought about it
reply
10.8k sats \ 2 replies \ @ek 21 Feb
I think I never thought as much about it as while writing this reply so thanks for asking. I also think I didn't even use the term "war dramas" before but it's very accurate to describe what kind of shows I like to watch lol.
I think shows that try to be historically accurate and portray characters as (flawed) humans interest me for three key reasons:
  1. Historical accuracy itself
  2. Gateway to look up all kind of interesting stuff, especially technological progress and politics
  3. The timeless human aspect: dealing with PTSD1, taking someone's life you never met (maybe even in close combat), seeing your friends die and deal with survivor's guilt, having to write letters back to families, ...
Historical Accuracy
Thanks to the historical aspect, you can basically see the technological progress in action. We went from fighting with sticks, bows and horses to bayonets, rifles, tanks, artillery, bombers etc. The maximized incentives (life or death scenario) are a catalyst for such progress. Michael Saylor in the Saylor series on the What Is Money show by Robert Breedlove goes in depth in this technological progress. One phrase that Saylor said in this series stuck with me: "There is no such thing as a fair fight [in nature]."2
But war fortunately not only accelerates the ways we can kill each other but also other technology that is useful in many ways. For example, cryptography and cryptanalysis got pretty important in WWII due to the widespread use of radio communication which can easily be intercepted. This was naturally very interesting to me. Some sources say that breaking the Enigma code was crucial for the Allies to win the war. Stuff like this isn't usually mentioned in shows but the (counter)intelligence part is. For example, mission briefings are all about intelligence: What kind of information do we have? How was this information gathered? Is it trustworthy? Is it accurate? What do we do with it?
Gateway to Other Interesting Stuff
You can also use shows about wars to get generally interested about the era it happened in since wars are like the climax of politics.
For example, I believe my "real interest" in wars started with playing Rising Storm 2 which is a first-person shooter set in the Vietnam war with an emphasis on realistic mechanics (one shot usually kills). It had a "Woodstock experience" setting where your visuals changed to being on Acid. This made me look up stuff about the Summer of Love, the War on Drugs, the Nixon Shock and the end of the Bretton Woods system which all happened in the same political era. So you could say I learned about the history of money simply by playing a video game and looking stuff up related to it.
Similar things are true for shows like Band of Brothers and The Pacific.
The Timeless Human Aspect
Shows only give you a glimpse of it since screen time is limited, it depends on the actors and there is no good way to go into detail what a specific character is thinking without breaking the flow of the show. But as with every good show, character development is still important.
I found that reading books from veterans is very good to have empathy with them. Again, thanks to RS2, I read my first such book. It was Chickenhawk from Robert Mason who flew Hueys in a transport role during the Vietnam war.3 It was a great book and it got me hooked on reading more from other veterans. I especially liked it because it starts with his relatable desire to fly helicopters and the US Army gave him this chance since they would pay for his training.4 However, while training he did not imagine that he would fly helicopters while getting shot at one day. The vietnam war broke out after he graduated where he then developed PTSD and had to give up flying because of that. A very tragic story including the treatment of such veterans after the war (which relates back to the Summer of Love and the politics of the war).
What is also interesting is to watch a show and then read the book on which the show is based on and spot differences. Sometimes, these differences are only in detail, sometimes, they are pretty big. The show was already pretty brutal but then you read the book and you're like... oh, that wasn't even close, lol.
I also like to watch interviews like this one from Major Dick Winters.

Footnotes

  1. Not sure if it was in the first episode but here is the link anyway. ↩
  2. Flying transport helicopters was my favorite part of the game. ↩
  3. This was very similar to what I almost did after school. I also wanted to become a helicopter pilot and was thinking about joining the military for this. I didn't since I didn't want to enlist for multiple years even if I wasn't able to go down the officer path and become a pilot. ↩
reply
455 sats \ 1 reply \ @k00b 21 Feb
Thanks to the historical aspect, you can basically see the technological progress in action.
I hadn't considered this, but it makes obvious sense. This is reason enough for me to try to get out of my comfort zone. Do you have a favorite tv war drama?
reply
Do you have a favorite tv war drama?
Band of Brothers and The Pacific haha. They are both short since they are miniseries from HBO with just 10 episodes à 1-2 hours each.
I don't know which one I like more. The Pacific is imo more "in your face" with multiple beach landings and the Japanese which rather blow themselves (and US medics trying to help them) up than to surrender. But BoB has more variety since it follows more different characters. For example, in BoB, one episode is about a medic during the Siege of Bastogne. The Pacific only has three main characters iirc.
I might also be biased towards BoB since it's a special feeling that the locations are kind of close to where I live.
If I had to pick, I would say start with BoB.
I also think I didn't watch any other tv war drama. I don't think there are many. Movies are usually too short for good character development.
reply