Being right can feel really good. I was a master of being right in my past life. I strategically set up my reality in such a way as to make sure I was always, “in the right”. I was the boss, the father, the provider. I always felt in control. No one around me could tell me anything because I was in charge of the situation, or least I thought so. When people spoke, I was crafting the perfect response to let them know how they were wrong. I was almost never listening. Even if we were in agreement, I would seek to be a contrarian, just for the sake of feeling right, safe, in control. I was very insecure.
When Bitcoin first started to click for me, I was excited. I was going to save everyone. I couldn't wait to interrupt people and tell them how wrong they were. And about this new magical internet money that was going to change their lives forever. But, they couldn't hear me. But... I knew I was right about this. How could they not see the truth. It was so obvious. Why won't they listen!!! It was quite frustrating.
With parenting, I have observed the same thing. When we talk to our children like adults, explain to them why things are the way they are, ask questions... They often grow to be our friends and allies. When we bark orders at them and tell them, this is the way it is because I am THE parent and you are MY child, they generally will fight back in some form. They want to understand, not be told what to do. Just like you and I.
So, these days, I do my best to listen first. If I hear people speaking on a topic of which I feel have insight, I first sit quietly... observe...listen intently...pause...consider. This helps me gather information and understand where they are coming from, so I may meet them where they are, as opposed to attempting to impose my radical reality. I learn a new perspective. If I do decide to offer my input, I aim to speak from a place of, "I don't know but maybe... What do you think?". I ask questions that have the potential to draw out the insight from the other, without any force.
I have noticed that us humans do not like to be told we are wrong. Even if someone just gives of a vibe that they are superior, or they know better, we pick up on that and we will not be in a place to receive new insights or perspective. No one wants to be talked down to. We are not able to convince each other of things. We may ask questions and guide in a way, but attempting to convince people tends toward a power struggle, where all parties end up deeper into their own close minded belief system. True insights always comes from within, with no force. You can lead a horse to water...
And to give up being “right”, does not mean to be “wrong”. Maybe, it can just mean every perspective is valid.
In my experience, this practice is incredibly freeing. I learn so much. I get to remain the student and grow with my fellow humans. When I approach an interaction with an open mind and heart, release the need to be right, I open myself up to new information. By asking more questions, I feel more able to teach others by allowing them to learn for themselves.
What happens when we give up the need to be right? Is there a such thing as right and wrong? Can we really save anyone?
I believe, when we show up loving, open, as a student, ready to listen, grow, and connect, we are far more effective in communicating our ideas and leaving an impact. What do you think?
I love to hear everyone's thoughts on this.
A fragile ego doesn't like to get be told they are wrong. I appreciate different perspectives because I live mostly in my head so wandering outside of it and hearing from other people that I respect is really helpful.
I don't always agree or listen to the other persons advice but it gives me something to think about. It either causes me to change my current course, or double down on it.
Listening and observing is great. You can hear a lot more from others by being aware than just asking questions and getting verbal responses.
reply
I relate to being in my head. Outside perspective is key to my sanity I think, lol
reply
deleted by author
reply
Good post
Giving up being right is a recipe for low blood pressure
reply
I believe in the mind, body, spirit connection. For me, needing to be right is kind of exhausting. When I carry less load, my body feels younger. I feel much healthier and younger than I did 10 years ago.
reply
Studying math was the most humbling experience in this regard. You are either right or wrong. Though sometimes you can be right and it is not as beautiful as it ought to be (actually got marked down points on my real analysis qualifier for this and if you can't tell I am still bitter). Kidding aside, you start get used to being wrong so its effect lessens. What's more, you start to enjoy testing things to see why it is wrong. I can't tell you how many times I had students ask me "what if we do this" in differential equations. My answer was always the same - let's try it. Even if I knew it would be wrong it was always a valuable learning experience.
In life, just like in math, being wrong, or making the less optimal decision, offers valuable insights. The person who makes the less optimal decision first learns why it didn't work, and can be more confident in future decisions. The person who got it right the first time might not know that the other solution would have been less optimal. This can lead to doubt and regret.
So:
what happens when we give up the need to be right?
Less anxiety and stress. More learning. Deeper conversations. Less anger.
Is there such a thing as right and wrong?
Yes. Though being wrong in hindsight doesn't imply you were wrong with the information you had at the time. As a stupid example, if the person who checks out behind you buys the winning lottery ticket, not buying the ticket was still the correct decision at the time the decision was made.
Here is my question - does it matter? Does it matter if we know there is right or wrong? Even if there is a right and wrong - Godel's incompleteness theorem proves there will be things that are unprovable in any system of logic with axioms that can be listed via an algorithm.
Can we really save anyone?
If the person you are trying to save is open to being saved.
And to give up being “right”, does not mean to be “wrong”. Maybe, it can just mean every perspective is valid.
I think this is a cop-out. It is effectively saying 'if I have to accept that I am not always right then I am going to avoid being wrong by saying there is no right or wrong.'
You could convince me I am wrong, though.
reply
I second your perspective about the humbling power of really studying math. If you're wrong, no amount of rhetorical flourishes or shifting the goalposts will convince anyone that you aren't wrong.
reply
Wow. Thank you for your thoughtful and insightful reply.
I always liked math as a kid because I thought I knew there was one right answer. I liked spelling too for the same reason. I believed the teacher couldn't subjectively judge my work. Of course that was middle school and highschool. I'm basic when it comes to math.
I feel that right and wrong are words we came up with. Everyone has a different perspective and experience, which informs what they believe to be right or wrong. There is always an exception to a rule and depending on our version of the events, or our interpretation of the story, we may or may not see the exception. We seem to have social contracts and common beliefs that are very natural. Be kind to each other. I feel I act this way because it is natural for me. Not because it is right. And who is to be the ultimate decider of what is right and wrong assuming there is "a right" and "a wrong".
reply
I once wrote a post why Bitcoin doesn't have to be "right": #159684 because Bitcoin already has achieved its goal.
I think perspective shifts like this are valuable to think about in general for every topic. At least play with the thought of what being "right" actually is.
reply
I agree. And I enjoyed your post. Thanks
reply
Here here.
I learned this in a very different way, however. I'm married to someone who must be right so often that it's basically an automatic argument when I offer my own opinion on any subject at all.
Even if I have direct evidence of something that she doesn't know about yet, simply presenting that evidence will make me wrong because how dare I go against her position! I swear, it's like I'm living in a Chinese emperor's court or something...
Anywho, the only way our marriage has survived is by me learning to shut up and listen... To learn her perspective completely. And when I do that & still realize that she's simply uniformed on the subject, I then have to find a way to let HER discover the contrasting information instead of just presenting it to her.
It takes a lot of playing dumb which, unfortunately, just enforces her decision that she's always right.
reply
That is a great example. I feel you on that.
reply
And to give up being “right”, does not mean to be “wrong”. Maybe, it can just mean every perspective is valid.
I agree 🤙
reply
Personally, the same thing has happened to me, I even think the same thing has happened to all of us, it is quite difficult to deal with it, but I agree with your reflection. Taking a pause and listening and then seeing how we can awaken their interest is more effective than imposing something from the start. just because!! . Although we are right
reply