Need.. probably not. Since 2014ish, I've always signed txs from an air gapped device (outside of lightning's hot wallet).
IMHO is too much paranoia with these HW. Use the 3 levels stash method and your hodl stash is absolutely secure. I had in the past some HW but I gave them away to noobs. Not useful for me at all.
Read more here:
But if you want to use those HW, go ahead... more sats for me.
reply
I still have an offline setup that I use regularly. But my main use case is for when I leave this world. No one in my family would be able to understand my setup and recover anything.
reply
Why do you care what happen after you are gone? If they are not capable to obtain voluntarily the BTC from you meanwhile you are alive, that means they do not deserve them.
reply
I know people that use a HW but then they store the seeds of the HW in a book on their desk, or in the notes application of their phone. I've seen it with my own eyes.
reply
Like this one? šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚
reply
Man I have a pile of those from the late 90's that I should throw to trash because I don't have a disk reader anymore, and the content of them are pure ancient bullshit.
reply
Literally me.
reply
if you want to use those HW, go ahead... more sats for me
I guess, I can find answer to the obvious follow up how question in your posts, but could you perhaps explain what do you mean?
reply
I mean that meanwhile some others are buying a lot of HW, I will stack more sats, not buying them. There are many methods to secure your wallets, without any expensive HW. But yes, require some basic knowledge of software and simple steps to do.
Yeah people love to buy these fancy toys, to feel more secure and create complicated multisigs for what? To keep 1BTC or not even that?
Multisig with multiple HW is necessary only when you a big company with multiple people accessing the company funds. But for a single user is over-complicating things for absolutely nothing.
Example here:
Please take the BTC if you can.
reply
Understand. Thanks.
reply
"Require some basic knowledge of software". How did that work out for Luke? A basic offline single purpose signing device can help a lot of people not shoot themselves in the foot. They can still do it, but it helps lower the chances.
reply
Luke is a really bad example for this.
  1. We still don't have the certainty that everything he said is true. Maybe was just a way to make "a boating accident"...
  2. Devs like that usually do mistakes
  3. Just because he's a bitcoin dev, that doesn't mean he cannot do stupid things or the methods are not good.
As I show that simple example with steganography. Try to take the BTC if you can. But Luke not even that he did... he kept all his (supposedly) BTC in just one place. As I recommended: use the 3 levels stash. And each level will have multiple wallets.
Please read the guide I linked above.
reply
I think steganography is awesome, but using a hardware wallet is a much more straightforward standardized process. Walking normy friends through steganography seems like too heavy a lift.
reply
Sure. I am not saying that normies should use my methods. Every user can use whatever method they are comfortable with. I only wanted to point out that not only a HW is safe. I see this trend pushed everywhere and new users think that is the only way.
reply
Thanks for the guide by the way. Book marked.
reply
I managed to extract the sats from the cat picture šŸ˜
Can I keep it?
reply
reply
What do you propose for people securing considerable sums? For instance, wealthy people wanting to put some of their money in bitcoin and take self custody of it without too much compromises in terms of security? Do you think self/collab custody with hw wallets makes sense for them?
reply
Is not about the amount. Is about the user capabilities and knowledge how to use wallets and software. I explained in this guide all stages of how to level your stash in 3levels. https://darth-coin.github.io/beginner/be-your-own-bank-en.html
reply
Ok, put it this way: newbies that want to acquire 5-10 bitcoin but don't have the skills to do so. What would you propose them as a solution that is secure but user friendly (not a lot of technical skills needed).
Would you propose them a singlesig or multisig? Would you advise them to make wallets on Tails USBs or to buy hw wallets from different vendors?
Would your advice be the same for 100 bitcoin?
reply