0 sats \ 11 replies \ @kepford OP 3 Apr \ parent \ on: Caesar’s Realm, God’s Kingdom: Anarchism as a Biblical Response to Earthly Power libertarian
Ok, not sure why you are wasting your time commenting.
For others that see this thread. Anarchism is a big tent. There are indeed people that believe there should be no order, no hierarchy, no one should ever be compelled to do anything. This is more in line with socialist anarchism. Anarcho-capitalism holds that governance/order/hierarchy is both good and needed. Its not no rules but no rulers. Or more to the point no monopoly on violence. Voluntary governance is all around us and works quiet well. Most anarchists especially those that are also Christians believe in governance in God's kingdom, churches, and the family.
If this sounds interesting to anyone I recommend watching the video. If not, move along.
One last thing. I've never heard ANY libertarian or anarcho-capitalist accused of sounding hip or cool. Quite the contrary.
I addressed the fundamental tenet on which the argument rests as a way to save time. Since that tenet is absurd, other people will either realize the truth of the position, or they will invest their own time in watching this video.
Anarchy and God's kingdom are mutually exclusive. God is not an anarchist. It's very simple.
reply
Again, you are making an argument I don't disagree with and the video isn't saying that at all. If you aren't curious that's fine but don't assume you know the position of the video or myself.
God's kingdom only has one king. That's kinda the whole point of the video :)
reply
Most anarchists especially those that are also Christians believe in governance in God's kingdom, churches, and the family.
If you aren't curious that's fine but don't assume you know the position of the video or myself.
Whatever you are trying to do here isn't cute. You cannot be a Christian and an anarchist. You might be a Christian and an extremist or something, but not an anarchist.
reply
lol, I never said I was an anarchist. I'm not actually neither is the speaker in the video...
reply
You spoke on behalf of "most anarchists". That made it seem like you were one.
reply
I used to identify as one. I agree with many things they say and believe but I serve one master and it isn't me. No king but Christ. This whole thread is an example of why I actually don't like labels because it is to easy to write things off because you think you know what the other person is going to say before they say it.
Also, it is totally fine to ignore me but this post is something I shared and I won't leave arguments with a ghost go unanswered. You might be surprised how much you agree with the video. Maybe not. You be you.
I've come to the position that the systems of this world are evil and this includes every government. Some are more evil than others but they have become false idols worshiped by many who claim Jesus as lord with their lips but their hearts and actions point to a worship of power. It is very similar to the one ring in the Lord of the Rings. If we can just gain power we can do the good things we want but the power corrupts them. More often than not though those that seek power are evil and do not want to do good at all.
American Christians seem to be especially guilty of this. They seem to still believe that if they could only elect the right people things would be great. My reading of the Bible and specifically the example of Jesus point to an opposite path. Jesus came to overthrow the hearts of man, not the governments. Governments are powered by belief. When the people stop believing the lose their power.
reply
Also, it is totally fine to ignore me but this post is something I shared and I won't leave arguments with a ghost go unanswered.
The only ghost you should be worried about is the Holy One, and if you are arguing with it, well, who has the problem?
If we can just gain power we can do the good things we want but the power corrupts them.
Christ IS the power. Your theology needs some work. These videos aren't going to help you with that.
reply
And you were dead in the trespasses and sins in which you once walked, following the course of this world, following the prince of the power of the air, the spirit that is now at work in the sons of disobedience— among whom we all once lived in the passions of our flesh, carrying out the desires of the body and the mind, and were by nature children of wrath, like the rest of mankind.
Ephesians 2:1-3 ESV