pull down to refresh

In other words, this one entity holds the keys to at least 47 out of every 100 freshly mined bitcoins

What is the reason pools and etfs and things don't hold their own keys? They aren't stupid people, they aren't lazy or scared (reasons that might apply to individuals who don't hold their own keys). Is it just convenience or a regulatory issue?

Steve Barbour and Rijndael further discuss here:

view on twitter.com
@checksum0 Lots of people have demonstrated there is a custody agreement involving Antpool, and possibly F2Pool, for smaller pools (quite a long list).

I'm theorizing Antpool are building blocks for them too (excluding F2Pool), thus controlling all the hashrate for those, by proxy.

@SGBarbour Yes, I thought this was well known.

Bitmain is also backing / financing a significant % of gross market hashrate (hardware + infra). They are also backing / doing sweetheart deals with lots of software infra.
reply

I see this diversifying this cycle with options like ocean and I’m sure many more.

reply

This is why I am mining with ocean.xyz now. I think this is important for the Bitcoin future.

reply

Braiins didn't do that until they went FPPS. I believe it's the result of a big player providing all the FPPS backing, making essentially all FPPS pools just front-ends for that one big backer.

reply

Should have used Ocean pool

reply

Who's the custodian? Coinbase?

reply

I don't know, from the thread it looks like it is unclear. He says in a previous thread it is something called Cobo, but he doesn't sound too certain.

reply

Maybe bitgo

reply

it’s probably a low tech version of stratum v2, where they agree to share variance, and have a centralized entity escrow the coins and pay them out pro-rata

reply

They aren’t holding a lot, it’s like a hot wallet sum to us.

reply

I agree with you! This just leads to centralization which is the exact opposite of BTC!

reply

Yeah, it doesn't seem good.

But I don't think people make stupid decisions in general, so I really want to figure out: what is the motivation here?

We all think that centralization is bad and trusting somebody else to hold your keys is bad, but here are people with a ton of skin in the game doing exactly the opposite of what makes sense.

Dude fuck coinbase. It's an exchange, not a wallet. They just want you to treat it like one so they can claim your coins

reply

From these kind of tweets, it feels like Bitcoin's decentralization is under attack.

reply

Isn't it only when they want to sell?

reply

Amazing! BITCOIN isn't decentralized anymore.

reply

Let's change over to bch

reply

Nope! That's the same kid out of bitcoin.

reply

That was a joke

reply

I know. Haha...I made another ioke

reply

Let's make some bsv jokes here around....

reply

Why jot I am in.

reply

They'll kick our a.... here