Sometimes I wonder what led us down the path of idiocy and then I see takes like this which show how far the education system has fallen. Starting off at the most basic basic level this bill directly states Bitcoin is protected so boom bam whadda wam its fine. Second and a little bit higher thinking than I think you are used to or can do... Laws get nuked all the time in the US for creating favoritism. If you want to protect BTC you have to protect crypto you cannot exclude others from protection without lawsuits and then the law being struck down.
reply
Except... bitcoin and shitcoins ARE different. Looking at the Howey test: for example eth is clearly a security imo. Bitcoin clearly is not.
reply
You might thing a 1939 law links with ETH if you want but I don't. I see ETH almost as an internet of sorts but the internet isn't a security. Both require things to operate within them and esp in the internet's founding it was hella expensive to have internet those AOL free trial CD's were practically gold.
reply
However, that being said, I would basically abolish securities law too, so...
reply
The law ought to protect Bitcoin and shitcoins alike. Equality before the law is essential for Bitcoin's long term success. Let the market kill the shitcoins, not the politicians
reply
deleted by author
reply
They flip flop on the content they decide is real BTC or not, no big deal, lol.
reply
Is Bitcoin crypto now?
From a legal POV? Yes. Otherwise, you need the politicians to craft a law that distinguishes the two. Sure, you could have proof of work and decentralized inserted into the definition, but even there you won't eliminate all the coins out there. And the law could give a shit about being first or the network effect or any of that.
And whatever you think about shitcoins, if you're opposed to government interference and support free speech, that means in all cases, not just for things you like. Otherwise, those aren't principals, just word.
reply
It blows my mind how people cannot understand exactly what you said. The law of the land at the end of the day has to be equal and not create favoritism or it ends up in court and eventually gets struck down. By protecting crypto you protect BTC and alts. If you hate shitcoins/alts/etc then just don't by them but why on Gods green earth would people rather them not protect BTC because of it is beyond me.
reply