295 sats \ 0 replies \ @Undisciplined 18 May \ parent \ on: Can you be considered a great player if you never win it all? Stacker_Sports
I think I agree with you. I'd add, though, that it should be obvious that a player is making winning plays, in order to be considered great.
Barry Sanders is a great example for this. Sometimes a great player gets stuck with a loser franchise, but it's clear that they are elevating the team well beyond where they would otherwise be.