Just a couple of days ago, Shelley Duvall, star of The Shinning, died. He died at 75 years of age. And the question I can ask myself is: how much of that life was shortened by the suffering caused by the filming of that movie? Was it really necessary for Stanley Kubrick to psychologically abuse her to get his supposedly perfect shots? Didn't Kubrick know that an actor can do things without reaching that level of abuse? The Shinning is a great movie but a terrible adaptation. It works visually, but not narratively. The madness of its protagonist appears out of nowhere, without a development arc. Infinite takes for a film that Stephen King himself rejects. The sign of a narcissistic egomaniac who exaggerated his methods. We have dozens of directors who did not need to torture their actors and actresses to make great films. Kubrick, like others, chooses to believe that it is necessary to suffer for an illusion, to strengthen what is actually the fear of not being as perfect as they believe they are. In between, Shelley Duvall endured a lifetime of suffering for just one movie. It doesn't matter how good or bad that movie is. She didn't deserve that treatment, nor does anyone deserve it. Now all that remains is a prayer for his rest.
this territory is moderated
Needed some background.
Also read a recent article stating that she once said she does not regret working for Kubrick for this movie.
But still, one is left to wonder...
reply
She changed her opinions about Kubrick. Sometimes she blamed him, sometimes she defended him. I think that's part of the trauma that movie caused in her spirit and mind. It's ridiculous that a scene requires 127 takes, that's absolutely absurd. Sometimes a filming causes problems. The protagonist of The Exorcist had problems with her spine, neck, etc., due to the complexity of the scenes. But they were accidents, it's not that the director wanted to make her suffer to prove a point. I think Kubrick wanted to make people suffer. As Lars Von Triers currently does. But perhaps we will never know the truth of what Duvall suffered.
reply
Yeah, trauma does that to people. We will perhaps never know indeed.
I kinda wanna rewatch some of his movies now though. Clockworks orange comes to mind of course. I watched it as a 15 year old in school, that was an intense experience...
reply
The Kubrick film I want to see again is Full Metal Jacket. There are some very good and strong scenes.
reply
I didn't even know she had died, I found out from this post. so sad. yes, a prayer for Shelley Duvall, my friend.
reply