They don't necessarily get any additional power. "Sheriff" is just a way of sticking with the western motif.
The real rationale for why this works is that it coordinates turn taking and therefor sharing in the costs of punishing bad actors.
I like the idea that everyone has the power to downzap, instead of one person wielding the power.
reply
Everyone would still have the power to downzap. "Sheriff" would have about as much meaning as our cowboy hats.
The experimental literature indicates that this can be enough.
reply
Interesting. I guess it might be a feature worth trying?
reply
Yeah, I gotta agree. Sounds like an interesting experiment.
reply