I showed you, and you recognized yourself, that it was the abandonment of central planning the reason of China economic growth, hence the phase of liberalization of the economy. Liberalization of the economy replaced central planning, it didn't "combined" with it, because they are opposites. I showed you the examples, and you accepted them. The reason why you insist to abstract yourself from that reality and insist in such an imaginary combination, in despite of having accepted it doesn't exists, escapes me.