pull down to refresh

@Rothbardian_fanatic shared how he feels that the Japanese educational system only churns out mindless robots instead of developing one’s individuality. I agree with him, and I still have a lot of good things that I like about Japan’s educational system. I have been working on this article on months and have wanted to share 10 points, but I guess now is as good a time to share as any.
  1. Interclass competitions. School life in Japan is really fun, and I like how it encourages its young to develop collaborative skills. I fondly remember a lunch period with a 7th grade class, in which the boys and girls discussed how to arrange themselves for the inter-class relay and maximise their chances of winning. (Yes, every single member in the class has to run the relay.) Also noteworthy is the inter-class chorale competition, in which the homeroom teacher marshals his or her charges through hours of dedicated practice to have a shot at winning. I think such events enable teenagers to discover their strengths and weaknesses while contributing to something greater than themselves.
  1. I loved it when Japanese schools maintained close connections with the wider community. In Kumamoto City, the fifth graders were involved in the planting of rice seedlings with the local farmers. Getting themselves literally dirty and braving the elements surely fostered a deep appreciation of food. Similarly, all sixth graders would be attached to a local enterprise for a job shadowing experience for three days. This would enable them to get acquainted with the adults and understand the role they had to play in contributing to society. I think education cannot be divorced from society, so it’s bodacious that Japanese education helps young minds find their place in the world.
  2. Japanese schools place a premium on cleanliness — to the extent that they dedicate one whole period of 45 mins to cleaning every day. And it wasn’t just lip service. Everyone, including the principal, would be hard at work cleaning his allocated portion of the school. You may be cynical and ask if students can really be unsupervised and left to their own devices. Well, I wouldn’t say that everyone was cleaning diligently. Some were obviously going through the motions, but I dare say that no one was slacking off. The Japanese are renowned for leaving a place cleaner than when they encounter it. Just look at the World Cup, and I believe their desire to keep things spick and span is cultivated from a young age.
  3. Japanese people generally live long lives, which may be related to how they are conditioned to exercise regularly from a young age. This doesn’t bode well for the work-life balance of long-suffering Japanese teachers, but students train very hard for their sporting co-curricular activity. Every day after school, until the sun sets. Sometimes they even have training or friendly matches on weekends (Yes, their teacher-in-charge will have to be with them). Add to that the fact that it’s not uncommon for middle school students to run as long as 25 kilometres — in winter. Japanese people are said to have deep reservoirs of resilience. Pushing their bodies to the limit might be one reason why.
  4. To be honest, when I was living in Japan, I was flabbergasted at how the Japanese don’t impart the Hiragana alphabet at preschool level, having come from education-obsessed Singapore. I was used to a rigorous approach to education. Pre-schoolers in Singapore were expected to be able to read, write and do simple arithmetic by the time they reached primary school. Then, I was shocked to find Japanese kindergarten kids running around the playground, shouting to their hearts' content for the few times I was attached to a preschool as the special guest of the day. I think that if I hadn’t visited there to teach them simple English, they wouldn’t have done anything remotely academic! Now that I’m a father, I have since realized the importance of unstructured play — how it develops neural pathways and boosts creativity. I respect how the Japanese education system allows full reign for young children to be themselves.
  5. I'm not exactly sure the reason for the influx in students with special educational needs these days. Perhaps it has to do with how processes have been improved, leading to more prompt diagnoses. But one thing's for sure. I have tremendous respect for how the system allocates one teacher to take care of the idiosyncratic needs of just 1-2 students. I actually asked one special education teacher during a drinking session about his pay compared to mainstream teachers. He revealed that he was paid comparably. Having come from a pragmatic country, in which organizations will try to optimize the value they extract from every individual, I was filled with immense respect at how the Japanese recognized the support needed by learning needs students and made provisions for it in their remuneration.
  6. The devil is in the details, and Japanese teachers intentionally pursue their craft very earnestly. The concept of lesson study observation has caught on in Singapore in recent years, but a decade ago, it was already part and parcel of every Japanese teacher's portfolio. Ever so often, the entire school would be granted early dismissal, save for one class. This allowed teachers the space to congregate in the classroom with that sole class and observe the subject teacher in action. From the few sessions that I have had the privilege to observe, it seemed that the teachers took this seriously. They would gather at a classroom after the lesson and critically dissect all aspects of it. I marvelled at how the entire staff took the time out to process through their teaching practice and brainstorm of ways to refine it. I was glad to watch them exhibit the spirit of Kaizen (continual improvement).
this territory is moderated
How do Japanese schools (or Singapore for that matter), deal with students who fall behind grade level? Do they get held back or are they moved forward to the next level?
reply
@Rothbardian_fanatic has answered the Japanese context adequately, so let me fill you in on my country’s situation xP
Oh we have zero qualms about holding students back if we think that they are not up to par. Let me scope our realities in the example of pre-tertiary education. We have two years of high school education, termed junior college one and junior college two. When our 18-year-old teenagers are in JC2, they need to sit for the GCE Cambridge A Level exams. So, many junior colleges retain their JC1 students (can be as many as 100 odd out of a cohort of 700-800 students) for one year because the teachers deem that they are ill-prepared for the rigours of this pivotal life-changing exam.
I think the Asian concept of “saving face” has a role to play here. Being a small country, we all know which junior colleges perform the best. So zealous principals and middle managers mayn’t want to send their weakest students to the battlefield because they will lower the college’s median grades haha. We are a rather competitive society here
reply
The way that the Japanese schools handle it to my knowledge is they never have kids falling behind grade level unless they are in the hospital or out sick for a long period. They usually have a four or five student team (gumi) with students of varying skill levels, so the whole team works through the assignments, helping each other along the way. This operates much like the old one-room school houses did long ago in the US. The “older” students teach the “younger” students what they have learned previously or during that lesson. The whole team moves together. This way everyone stays at grade level and passes to the next grade.
reply
They actually don’t come out of school as mindless bots, because they have been exposed to a lot of different competitive activities. They are also channeled into after school “school” (juku) where they either sharpen a skill that school teaches or learn something different from everyday classes, like abacus or flower arranging or a traditional sport. This does differentiate the students so they don’t come out as bots. Also high school is not compulsory, so there are different kinds of high schools; academic, agricultural, business and industrial schools. Everyone comes out different but very conforming to the template the state gives to the schools.
Sorry, I didn’t read the complete blurb under the title and zapped you anyway! Silly me!! :)
reply
Yes, the real 勝負 is at the cram schools. Even though the Singapore educational system pays a lot of focus on academics, most parents still send their kids to tuition centres, fearing that their offspring will lose out to their peers if they don’t spend their entire waking hours cramming. I guess that’s Asian societies for you. Singapore is reputed to be a meritocratic society, but in recent years, the rich-poor divide has widened, making it hard for poor kids to get perfect grades and break out of the poverty cycle.
Although I believe in the value of an all-rounded education, I still think both the Japanese and Singapore systems don’t do full justice to their charges because we don’t succeed in realising their full academic potential.
reply
Does anybody ever reach their full academic potential without serious individual study and effort? I don’t really think so. People have to take their own destiny in hand to fulfill anything they are doing.
reply
Two comments:
  • On a trip to Japan once, I walked by a what looked like a middle school. In the playground, they had a neatly hung up set of...unicycles! I wish I had seen them actually being used, but the kids were inside. But, what a fun thing for kids to have available - and it sure wouldn't have happened in the US because of "safety".
  • I've had occasion to interact with a number of Japanese teens, visiting the US for a "language exchange". It always shocked me, how bad their English was. It was mostly truly terrible, especially considering that they told me they'd studied English for long period of time - like 7 years, 10 years. How is that even possible?
reply
The language problem is due to how they teach English pronunciation. They teach English pronunciation using katakana, which are a Japanese syllabari, using their pronunciation. They lack several sounds in Japanese that we use in English, for instance: /f/, /v/, theta, the vocal theta, /r/, /l/ and any diphthongs that we use in English. We also lack some of the sounds that the Japanese use in their language, such as tsu, ra, ri, ru, re, or, fu, and all of the vowel portions of the syllables. So, we have an accent when we speak Japanese, too.
reply
I love how you gave a balanced view of the pluses and gaps of both English and Japanese
reply
Different languages are different. There are a lot of sounds that make up languages, but one language never uses them all, AFAIK. For me to learn one foreign language, I had to walk around the school saying the sounds that weren’t in my language. It took hours and hours to get them right. It also took a lot of feedback. Since I do not really have an ear for the tune of a language, I still have troubles, no matter how good my pronunciation is. You know you are having language problems when someone whose language you are speaking looks at you like you are speaking blather and doesn’t understand at all.
reply
what you described in points 2 and 3 sounds very cool, i would love it if shools here had anything remotely like it
reply
The reason they do it is to provide the students with a strong connection to the school and its property. Another is that they need fewer administrative personnel for maintaining the activities of the school. The students go on a lot of field trips around the school area. Sometimes they go on special trips, for instance flower or snow viewing or how tea is grown.
reply
And they were slippers in class
reply
They ware slippers because shoes are only for the outside, never inside.
reply
Everyone, including the principal, would be hard at work cleaning his allocated portion of the school.
What a fantastic image!
reply
That is just the usual thing in Japanese schools, especially elementary schools.
reply
And the regarding the disciplines ? How they are learning it ? model education ?...
reply
BTW, you did a very nice job with the essay! Very nice!!
reply