pull down to refresh

random server

Which random server?

Just take a look here how many apps already offer LN-auth. Apps that users already used. https://github.com/lnurl/luds

So cannot someone create a new one? Aren't anymore in the build mantra? :)

All the listed app are "monetary" wallet with support LN-Auth, this app aims to manage a specific use case removing the economic stuff, and I think can be useful in some areas don't mix ID and money.

Anybody is free to build any app. I am just saying that is useless to have a dedicated app just for LN-auth when I can use any other LN wallet for that. And as I said: with a LNbits instance (my own instance) I can have millions of different LN-auth, not just one, centralized in one app, with one identity.

Creativity doesn't mean is automatically useful.

reply

I think you haven't any right to decretate if something is useful in general :)

For example a similar app, for me, is useful because I can split the money context from the login one. Then a login only app has less code, so less attack surface and can be audited easier. As said can extend the login record with useful data (for example alternative method access, a login history, etc.) that you hardly find in a standard wallet.

It's wonderful if you are happy with your LNbits instance, perhaps someone else could prefer a simpler/different/specialized solution. The market chooses, right?

Criticism doesn't mean is automatically useful.

PS: You forgot to reply about the server matter

reply