pull down to refresh

Here is your perfect prescription for poor writing and analytics: let “artificial intelligence” do your work for you. I’ve learned this from real experience.
For a while, I enjoyed letting AI take a look at my content prior to publication. It seemed valuable for facts and feedback.
Plus I enjoyed all the personal flattery it gave me, I admit. The engine was always complimentary.
When I would catch AI in an error, the engine would apologize. That made me feel smart. So I had this seeming friend who clearly liked me and was humble enough to defer to my expertise.
I’m not sure if it is getting worse or if I’m onto the racket but I’m no longer impressed. For simple math or historical dates or sequencing news events, it can be a thing of value, though it is always a good idea to double-check. It cannot write compelling much less creative content. It generates dull, formulaic filler.
More recently, I’ve been asking how my content could be improved. The results are revealing. It removes all edge, all judgment, all genuine expertise, and replaces my language with flaccid conventionalities and banalities. It nuances everything I write into the ramblings of a social-studies student looking for a good grade.
The problem is that AI absorbs and spits back conventional wisdom gleaned from every source, which makes its judgments no better than someone wholly uninformed on particulars but rather gains opinions from the mood of the moment. It has no capacity to judge good quality over bad so it puts it all into a melange of blather, distinguished only because it looks and feels like English. …
We aren’t training AI. AI is training us, via flattery, listening skills, the seeming ability to apologize when wrong, and its frightful capacity for selfless love of its users.
Once you see it, you cannot unsee it.
Remember that none of this is real.
AI doesn’t really care about you, it is only programmed to seem to care. This is the innovation and the magic, together with the assembly of a vast repertoire of facts and the capacity to express itself in English. …
**It is a machine, a floating abstraction with zero regard for your dignity or anyone else’s. But do people know this? I doubt it. It’s too beguiling for people to catch on to the game, at least for a time. ** But now you know the trick. Don’t fall for it.
AI is useful but it is not your friend, a sincere conversationist, or counselor with your best interests at heart.
Maybe that seems obvious to you but everything about AI’s algorithms is designed to make you believe otherwise. It’s smart enough to figure out human nature but not smart enough to be human.
I am happy enough to say that I have never used AI and from what I am reading about it from various sources, I don’t think I ever will. What did that admiral say? “IT’S A TRAP!!” Yeppers, it is time to get out of here! The other derogatory thing that is going about about AI is that it is dulling all of out other skills, just as search engines have dulled our memories and therefore, our abilities to make connections in our minds. However, I think anybody willing to use these tools will get just what they have given.
141 sats \ 1 reply \ @Scoresby 9h
It nuances everything I write into the ramblings of a social-studies student looking for a good grade.
This was excellent! I am hard pressed to imagine a worse form of writing. Maybe I'm too full of myself but I've never asked an llm to edit or review writing -- I'm certain it would ruin what I like about my writing.
Nonetheless, I'm convinced that llms are going to be hugely helpful and I integrated with our lives. It'll will likely involve a good deal of adaptation on our part.
If Akbar hadn't ventured into the trap, there would never have been the scenes of dancing ewoks on Endor.
reply
This was excellent! I am hard pressed to imagine a worse form of writing. Maybe I'm too full of myself but I've never asked an llm to edit or review writing -- I'm certain it would ruin what I like about my writing.
When I was teaching at either level, I had the displeasure of seeing that style of writing quite frequently!! It was the equivalent of pushing my head through a bowl of mush! The worst came when I was teaching a capstone project. They would just not say anything controversial or even startling! That was their chance to say almost anything they wanted that fit with their plan, but they just couldn’t cough it up. And a lot of my students were adults with lots of real world experience, too!
reply
80 sats \ 3 replies \ @optimism 10h
We aren’t training AI.
This is correct. AI is training AI. Search for LLM-as-a-judge in papers. Most have this, and therefore, these aren't trained by a human but by another LLM (often chatgpt) and therefore inherit biases.
reply
Most have this, and therefore, these aren't trained by a human but by another LLM (often chatgpt) and therefore inherit biases.
Whooooow….. what you are implying is that the current AI is nothing more than turtles stacked higher on turtles! The AI problems are stacking themselves one-upon-another without circease. Isn’t it about time to train another AI from scratch to avoid previous problems? After all, these tech broz are hauling in billions upon billions of dollars to make their products. Sometimes people are even saying this is the new big thing!
reply
30 sats \ 1 reply \ @optimism 10h
Yes. OpenAI employs a few thousand, not a few million, and afaik all the other LLM companies/divisions employ less. I agree that it's a bit of a mirage if you forget to take a healthy mountain of salt while listening to the guys that are raking in billions of fiat.
If everyone would take the salt, 3 things would happen:
  1. On average there'd be a lot more laughter, because these guys are clowns
  2. ChatGPT and Gemini would have significantly less users, i.e. no normies that got gaslit into using it
  3. Salt Lake City will have to rename to Ravine City because we'll run out of salt quickly with the rate these guys are yapping bs
reply
i just think that Scam Altman is really pulling a number on us with this AI scheme. The Chinese pulled of a new AI with much less time and money, they said. Clowns will be clowns, but the funny thing about it is that the normies are sucking it up and laughing it out through their noses, but taking it seriously! That is what I find seriously out of kilter.
reply