No, she was into it too quickly and she’s had two different instructors already. 

I think it’s just a great activity for kids with her temperament.

Sounds like fun - the investigative approach you are adopting haha. Could it be that she really likes her swimming instructor - his sense of humour etc?

cryotosensei

Exactly! That's why I want to learn from the swimming example and make her other settings ones she can thrive in without radically changing her personality.