He is possibly correct. Now it is up to the community to call his bluff. The reason he says it will pass is because traditionally subreddits have only gone dark for a day or two. This would be the first time in Reddits history that is extended.
Some have pointed out that other subreddits will be made and fill the void eventually. This is true, but this still shifts the tone of the content and overall vibe. I think this is what the CEO is relying on. Eventually people will just sort of move on and the subreddits that went dark will get replaced.
You will start to notice all platforms really digging in on the need to chase profit all of the sudden. Even at the cost of growth. The economic environment has changed and to me it is obvious what that means. Any company that had been ignoring profit in order to grow now needs to completely flip it around.
A lot of media companies are unprofitable and can never make a profit. Live streaming platforms are one of them. The biggest one is also not profitable. They have been increasing their advertising operations in order to make profit and still have not been able to. They have made extremely hostile changes towards their viewers and creators.
If the economy flips and we start printing money again these platforms will be fine. But until then they are all going to freak out. My conspiracy is without cash flooding the economy VC and advertising capital just vanishes and that is what triggers these companies to pivot out of growth mode.
Hell from their warped perspective I bet they think they are just firing their users to cut costs.
I don't really know what will happen from here. Will be interesting to see if the CEO's bluff gets called or what this looks like a few weeks from now.
reply
I think this is the end of reddit
reply
I think he's right. The age of protests has passed. It's time to vote with your feet and money.
A Sovereign Individual is not governed but also free from toxic corporate power.
reply
These social media sites like Reddit and Twitter were built in the fiat world. No way they work in a bitcoin world as they are designed now. I think what we are witnessing is the consequences of retraction of easy money. These companies need to make money now and the user is the product. These protests can come from a good place but are a waste of time. Just leave... use the next gen tools that are not build on this failing system and the models built on top of it. I get why these platforms are closing their API's. They have to monotize or die. I think they will die but your continued use of these platforms slow this death. Personally, I don't care if they die or go on. I have my own lines. If these protests make you feel good, ok that's fine but IMO it is a waste of energy. Just use the new gen tools like Bitcoin, Stacker, and Nostr.
reply
Unpopular opinion but I kind of understand Reddits stance here.
Reddits content is incredibly valuable for large language models. It is one of the few resources that have the heighest weight in commoncrawl together with Wikipedia and Stackoverflow.
They would be objectively giving value away for free if the API was just there.
reply
LLMs can easily scrape Reddit, no?
reply
At the moment and in the most recent version of commoncrawl: yes. After the 30. june 2023: no
If you want to have a taste of how it will be: try opening sites on linkedin (in your browser or Tor). Scraping is prevented easily and the API can be used for money.
reply
It's an arms race. There will be better tools for scraping, if there are not already. If these sites keep erecting walls they will end up affecting real users' UX which will backfire. So there's a limit to what they can do.
Information longs to be free and with enough determination it becomes free.
reply
Agreed, but I would argue that Reddit the company creates much less value than their users. Reddit is a utility, inflated to Big Tech status by cheap fiat money. Any company can run a bunch of servers and spin up a simple UI. Yes, they have strong network effects but I question how insurmountable that is. They need to respect the users who create most of the value.
SN solves this problem by paying users for participation. If they want to sell API access that brings in more funds, some of which are shared with users, well that's better for me.
reply
If catering LLM's is the goal reddit is taking a huge risk. Trying to make ML-ventures pay for reading reddit data and blocking all apps that generate content is too much collateral damage.
Most machine-learning ventures operate using a cloud-service or a single data-center. They scrap large amounts of data from a single IP.
In the case of reddit-is-fun each queries reddit using it's own IP-address.
Just rate-limiting per IP-address might solve this problem
reply
In the case of reddit-is-fun each queries reddit using it's own IP-address.
Just rate-limiting per IP-address might solve this problem
They don't want to "solve" this. They want Google and Microsoft to pay them!
reply