745 sats \ 3 replies \ @mudbloodvonfrei 18 Jun 2023 \ on: Competing with Apple and Google - A Weekend Discussion tech
Check this out: https://sailfishos.org/
It's Linux-based, but it has non-free components. For $50 you get the version with a closed-source but seemingly good Android emulator. I've seen some review videos and it seems promising. I would consider trying it out. I know I'll get some flak for supporting paid software, but I would love to financially support any company that offers a viable alternative to the Google/Apple duopoly. The more competitors, the lower the barriers to additional players. KaiOS had some promise a few years back but once they took funding from Google you could see where things were going.
I guess that doesn't exactly answer the OP question about how to create a new platform, but I think that what worked for Sailfish is that they allow you to maintain compatibility with Android. Google has very powerful network effects, it would be very difficult to take them head on.
I don't think there's any serious need to integrate bitcoin, but if this platform is developed by bitcoiners I think giving away some sats along with the device would be positive for bitcoin adoption. Having the OS use, by default, a nostr relay and LN node run by the company would create some network effects around the phone, albeit most likely weak ones.
IMO the closed source nature would be kind of a dealbreaker. Isn't GrapheneOS fully open source (and by nature, compatible with Android)?
I tried Sailfish on a Nexus 5 many years ago (probably 7 or 8 years at this point). It's nice to see that Sailfish is still going, but it's also not nice to see that they still haven't opened up their system fully despite that being the biggest complaint I've seen from Linux users wanting to make the switch.
reply
Isn't GrapheneOS fully open source
Depends on how you look at it. GrapheneOS only supports devices which recieve hardware firmware updates. That firmware is closed-source, but the OS entirely is.
There isn't really a 100% open-source phone anyway.
reply
I respect that. I also imagine it's a constant point of contention for the folks behind Sailfish.
It takes money to compete with Google and Apple. The fully open Linux on mobile distros like Ubuntu Touch, are half-baked; they're not for ordinary people, they're for tinkerers. I like to believe that Sailfish would release their code once they got traction (they could pivot to hardware for example), but for now, they have employees to pay
reply