While on my walk I was thinking about Bitcoin's biggest strength being decentralization and what parallels could exist in nature. I think its quite fascinating that Bitcoin is the invention of a top-down run species that is known for abusing control at points of centralization of power.
What other species exist out there where decentralization is the defining characteristic of how their members organize and act? Just speaking out of observation and not from any background in biology, I'd say ants and bees. Any more?
It depends on how you define decentralization. Ants, bees, termites operate in semi-autonomous fashion but with incredibly rigid behavioral repertoires and fixed roles, including more rigid hierarchies than anything humans have ever realistically constructed. So while the individual ant or bee is wandering around, and order is emerging from termite mounds, the larger context in which that order emerges is not like you intend, I don't think.
reply
Out of Control covers this exact line of thought in depth. It doesn't focus on decentralization intentionally but by focusing biological systems, whose complex forms are nearly always decentralized and require coordination, it's almost entirely about decentralized systems.
reply
Kevin Kelly is the king. His book What Technology Wants would probably be of interest to many bitcoiners.
reply
This is similar to thinking about anarchy. Anarchy means no rulers. No third party above the two+ parties in an interaction. Most of our interactions have no third party yet we seem to be programmed to believe anarchy will not work. Maybe I'm missing your point but I think it would be harder to come up with a non-decentralized structure in nature. It is complete anarchy with no central authority. You might have small parts like a wolf pack or ant colony that have centralized control but really... you can make a point that the "leader" is replaceable and just filling a function until their utility is gone. The system as a whole is decentralized.
reply
Indeed, despite every attempt governments have made, the free market still rules. It might be underground like drugs, it might use an abstract currency like food stamps (traded at or near parity for cash in inner cities) or cigarettes in prison. Its like water, it will fill every crevice in the cracked foundation of central planning, where you could name some of the centralized systems that run the show like the federal reserve system or the IRS, under the skin you have everyone actong in their own self interest to get over.
reply
Flocks of birds.
reply
Nature as a whole is a decentralised system that adapts and changes to the situation. There is no single creature (except man) that can or tries to assert absolute control.
reply
reply
This 👆. Also, read "Entangled Life" by Merlin Sheldrake.
reply
For some reason, the Portuguese man o' war came to mind for me. It's a dang crazy critter.
Portuguese man o' war characteristic // Analogy to bitcoin (?)
A "Pmow" floats around the ocean seemingly individually, but actually has the same DNA as all of the others "zooids" in its colony // A bitcoin node does its own thing but has the same bitcoin code; also, a bitcoiner does his or her own thing but we all are in consensus with the rules of the chain
The Pmows need each zooid to survive // Bitcoiners need miners to verify the chain and we also need users, traders, etc. and a community to keep bitcoin truly alive (miners alone MIGHT mean bitcoin is alive, but is it really? or is it just some computers running some software?)
My fave: Pmows literally sail the ocean with their "dorsal fins" or sails poking up out of the water. Somehow, they develop as either right or left "handed" sails. So, half of the group sails to the right and half sails to the left. This way, if they sail up on shore and die, it's only half of them...the other half sailed the other direction. // If bitcoin gets "shut down" in country X, country Y will continue on.
Pmows use their tentacles to zap little fish. // Bitcoiners zap zaps.
Pmows are cool. // Bitcoin is cool.
reply
Swarming behaviour comes to mind, eg shoals of fish, flocks of starlings etc. You'll see thousands of individuals working in beautiful coordinated unison without a central controlling authority, simply because each "node" is implementing basic self-preservation rules.
reply
deleted by author
reply
reply
Termites, similar to ants
reply
Nothing will beat Nostr in decentralization given time
reply
Mastodon is one
reply
THE SOLAR SYSTEM IS A DECENTRALIZED STRUCTURE.
reply
Not really, it has an all-powerful central controlling force governing precisely how it moves and behaves (the Sun), without which it would just be a bunch of independent rocks hurtling in random directions
reply
THE SUN NEEDS TO EXIST TO SURVIVE BUT IT CANNOT PREVENT THE PLANETS FROM USING ITS LIGHTS NOR ITS ENERGY. PLUS, THE PLANETS ARE NOT CENTRALZED IN THE SUN, THEY ARE FAR AWAY FROM EACH OTHER AND THEY REVOLVE ON THEIR OWN. I AGREE WITH YOU THE SUN IS A CENTRAL SOURCE OF ENERGY BUT, REMIMBER THERE IS ONE #BITCOIN LEDGER THAT TELLS THE ULTIMATE TRUTH, THE DIFERENCE THIS TIME IS THAT LEDGER IS EVERYWERE AND NOWHERE INSTEAD OF ONE SUN IN ONE PLACE IT'S ONE SUN TO LITE AND WARM EVERY HOME. LOL
reply