Question: Is it ever okay to say to someone, “life’s not fair”?
Answer: No. Never. Not ever.
First of all, “life’s not fair” is an inaccurate statement. Life is neither fair nor unfair. Life just is. It’s like saying, “the situation is hopeless”. Situations don’t have feelings…people have feelings. The situation isn’t hopeless. Instead, people are feeling hopeless about the situation.
lol, clearly not a toxic bitcoin maxi that wrote this. Sounds basically like:
Never ever tell people the truth, no one is able to handle it.
The funny thing is that the first episode of the Michael Saylor Series on the What Is Money? show goes in depth how nature isn't fair (and thus life) iirc.
I mean, knowing that life simply isn't fair means for me that sometimes, some things are just out of your control so maybe focus on what you can control?
And I would say this is a positive view? lol
But apparently this article goes to great lengths to not see it this way, lol
It's also horrible advice on many levels. It leads people to internalize everything: everything is their fault, for "feeling this way about it" to "not fixing it" when in fact you can't do anything about it and it is literally outside your control.
There's a famous (oooold) study in German sociology, the unemployed of Marienthal. A factory closed, the town died, people got all laid off. Nothing they did caused this, it was in a downturn and it just hit that town. The workers in that factory supported each other and all knew this wasn't their fault. They lost a lot of income, yes, but they didn't blame themselves and didn't fall into a black pit because of that. It was, for them, from their POV, unfair, but they weren't consumed by self-doubt because they framed it this way: unfair, not my fault.
The managers, on the other hand, with their social circle outside of the city, were excluded from their circles, gradually: they were in a culture in which the others did at least tacitly assume it was their fault, and the managers themselves also thought it was on them. That wasn't great for their future development. They did get consumed by self-doubt.
Sure, "life isn't fair or unfair, it just is", but from the position of people, it sure looks fair or unfair to them, and both of these takes are real. You can find people who thought all was fair in the example, and people that didn't, and it really is beside the point to argue over who's right. The point is that there are external influences that people can't control, no matter the moral assessment of those.
But psychology can't stand that. This is a larger problem of current psychology: it internalizes everything into behavior and body functions, learned practices and chemistry, and forgets there is a world out there outside the person (a common ailment of contemporary society). It does so for purely pragmatic reasons: the individual is something the profession of psychology can work on (and bill them for). it can't change the economic situation in a town, power dynamics at work, structural changes in an industry, technological developments, etc.
Another rule of organizational sociology: Organizations see the world through the lens of their practices. They order the world in categories they can be "responsible for" and work on, as that means they get to offer services and increase their prestige. They are allergic to any view of the world that takes away responsibility (and ability to do something) from them. This is what "causes" this bad, terrible, horrible advice.
reply
You just gave me a wonderful, if unexpected, insight into the psychologists' world.
This is a larger problem of current psychology: it internalizes everything into behavior and body functions, learned practices and chemistry, and forgets there is a world out there outside the person (a common ailment of contemporary society).
I have a few practising psychologists in my extended family and the above explains quite a bit of their behavior. (Not that I expect them to acknowledge that.)
reply
snowflake psychology.
Life isn't fair. The fact that we exist is incredibly lucky and that's not fair. The fact that we're having this conversation on a computer while so much injustice rains in the world. That's not fair. Our existence is an incredibly lucky, miraculous circumstance and we didn't deserve it, but we better enjoy it!
reply
yeah, i was actually searching for articles going in depth how exactly life isn't fair because another friend just mentioned to me how they thinks "X isn't fair" (it was about how health insurance works in Germany)
And I responded, well, so what? Life itself isn't fair. And I already know what this person is going to write me so I wanted to prepare myself with some good articles to send, lol
Then I found this, lol
reply
And I responded, well, so what? Life itself isn't fair.
Want to add here: I don't mean with "so what?" we shouldn't try to change the situation.
I mean we should exactly do that. But don't put your own interests lower just to make something "fair". Now life is just not fair to more people than necessary, lol. And it's going to be forever like that if everyone would just accept that it's not fair.
Maybe the difference is accepting vs acknowledging something? I don't accept that it's not fair. But I acknowledge it.
reply
I took so what as meaning that we shouldn't use the fairness of life as an excuse to not work for what we want to achieve.
reply