211 sats \ 4 replies \ @Undisciplined 24 Jan \ parent \ on: What Role Should Governments Play in Markets? history
Economies of scale have limits. Firms have the same problem as governments with a lack of internal profit and loss accounting. Eventually, that inefficiency overtakes economies of scale.
On the innovation point, I definitely think you're right about the prevailing attitude being one of fear, rather than optimism. I have a half-baked hypothesis about why new communications technologies bring down existing regimes. It might be that the US power structure was designed to be resilient to the types of communications technologies that existed before the internet and now they feel threatened by something they know they can't control.
interesting theory.
there’s a section in Bhu’s book that talks about radio and how challenging it was in the early days to prevent people from interfering with other broadcasts on the same frequency… which led to the government licensing of radio frequencies to maintain clean lines of communication
reply
It's a good example of how scientific advancements can require us to rethink our property rights framework.
I think market coordination could have solved that, though, since it's not in anybody's interest to broadcast an indecipherable message.
reply
it's not in anybody's interest to broadcast an indecipherable message
however, it could be in the interests of adversaries to make sure Americans are unable to hear important broadcasts, and this seems like without government intervention the costs for someone to interfere would remain incredibly low.
reply
I doubt adversaries care about having the proper FCC licensing. The ability to disrupt radio communications is readily available and it's easy enough to do without getting caught immediately.
The difference between a market solution and the government solution would be pretty minor, functionally. Instead of leasing the frequency from the government, radio operators would rely on arbitrators to recognize homesteading of frequencies based on who used it first. At least that's my guess.
reply