pull down to refresh

I just finished the third book of The Wheel of Time series. It's a very compelling fantasy world and before I get any further into it, I want to get a quick review up for any stackers who may be interested. I'll try to avoid any spoilers while giving a sense of what these books have to offer.

Overview

First, for those who have seen the Amazon series, the first two seasons roughly correspond to the first two books. However, there are some changes made by the adaptation that change the story significantly. I would describe those changes as HBO'ifying the series: the characters were made older, sexier, more violent and it's more of an action adventure than fantasy epic. I think the show is fine as its own thing, but it has a very different feel than the books.
Robert Jordan built a very intricate fantasy world that feels vast and rich. It's a fairly standard fantasy setting, with roughly medieval technology, various types of supernatural abilities, and recognizable but distinct mythical creatures.
Most people in this world live their entire lives near to where they're born and there are vast regional differences in what people believe about the world and its history. However, there is more or less a shared language and mythology.
The story is presented from one character's perspective at a time and the reader learns new information as the characters do. Much of the lore of this world is unknown to the characters we follow. What is generally known to all (or at least believed) is that the world was broken 3,000 years ago in a battle with Shai'tan the Lord of Darkness, Prince of Lies, and many other names associated with him. Also generally known/believed is that he had powerful magic users fighting on his side known as the Forsaken and that one powerful magic user known as The Dragon was responsible for breaking the world. This created a widespread distrust and fear of magic users.

The Eye of the World

The first book is very Tolkienesque. We learn about the people of a small remote region. They raise sheep and grow tobacco and enjoy their seasonal festivals. It's a quiet society that only receives news when the occasional merchant visits during harvest season.
Several teenagers from this town are reluctantly swept up in an adventure involving things they had believed to be entirely mythical. Their journey is arduous and written in a very grounded way that emphasizes how difficult and perilous travel in that setting would be. The show basically resorts to "fast travel" for this portion and totally loses the sense of distance travelled.
This book largely serves to explore the world through the eyes of characters who live in it, but are also largely unfamiliar with anything outside of their home.

The Great Hunt

Game of Thrones was inspired by the portion of this book about Daes'de Maer, the Game of Houses, that describes the political machinations amongst the nobility of one of the great cities.
This book introduces several major settings, including Tar Valon where the magic-using Aes Sedai live and train.
Much of the story revolves around a powerful and mysterious army arriving from the sea and making fantastical claims about their link to the history of the world known to our characters. This leads to uncovering how some of our characters are also connected to long past historical events.

The Dragon Reborn

A mystery in Tar Valon, an assassination plot, and a search for a missing member lead our scattered characters towards a seemingly impossible prophecy.
A great deal is learned about the sinister forces emerging in the world and what our characters may have to contend with in the future.

Takeaways

I had to be very brief in describing the later books for fear of spoilers. Much of the appeal of these books is following and anticipating the mysterious elements.
One of my favorite things about how this series is written is that the world feels very lived in. The cultures and places are detailed and distinct from each other. The characters have to make pragmatic decisions about where to stay and how to travel, based on factors like cost, time, and risk. Each of the characters also has a very distinct personality and seeing events from their varied perspectives gives a richer view of the story and a deeper understanding of the world. Also, each character serves a distinct role in the narrative. No one is just along for the ride.
The lack of an omniscient third person narrator really enhances the mystery of the story. We often don't know what certain people's motivations are or what the truth of a situation is and are left to puzzle it out alongside our characters.
747 sats \ 2 replies \ @siggy47 8 Feb
I just got a chance to read this. Damn fine write-up. I don't know anything about these books or the series, but now I'm interested. This is the type of quality review that will make this territory better.
reply
Thanks. It seemed a shame to just read for my own selfish enjoyment and not share with the stackers.
The fourth book is off to a great start, btw. I'll do these reviews book-by-book from here on out.
reply
305 sats \ 0 replies \ @siggy47 8 Feb
I'm looking forward to it. I got some work to do.
reply
My attention span is notoriously scattered these days, so I doubt I would have the stamina to finish one book, let alone the series. Still, what you wrote about the characters being shaped and adapting to their environment is intriguing and sounds universal.
Are there characters whom you relate to because of the way they see their world?
reply
I don't relate strongly with any of the main characters, beyond remembering what it was like to be a teenage boy. I am from a somewhat similar setting to most of the main characters (small mountain town in the woods) and similarly grew up learning some of the same skills they rely on.
There is a scholarly order of the magic users. None of them are main characters, but I do relate to them whenever they're around.
reply
It must be fun reminiscing nostalgically about your past while you read
reply
It is a little, but that's not the main effect. My familiarity with the setting mostly amplified how impressed I was with the detail included by the author. There were a ton of little things that I never would have thought to include, but that instantly brought me back to similar situations I've been in.
There's less of that as the books go on. More of the fantasy elements takeover.
reply
737 sats \ 1 reply \ @jurraca 7 Feb
I recently read book 2 & 3. I was intrigued by the daoist elements of the lore from the show which seemed fairly specific, and assumed the books would have more depth on this but it's more used as world building than anything else. The world is clearly inspired by daoism -- the fight of dark and light, the mentions of the taijitu symbol, the sword forms (directly drawn from tai chi sword), the five weaves of power match the five phases, the meditation the Void etc. The author def studied daoism closely. Overall i wasn't hooked but the books are pretty good.
reply
I haven't studied Daoism in detail, but I'm familiar with some of it through years of martial arts training, including tai chi.
I really like the incorporation of symbolism and stories from our world into the lore of the books as part of that world's history too.
reply
305 sats \ 2 replies \ @TheFish 7 Feb
Loved the series, will say books 7-10 were a bit of a grind though.
reply
Well, I probably won't get there for a couple of months still, so I'm glad the next few books are still engrossing.
reply
305 sats \ 0 replies \ @TheFish 7 Feb
Enjoy it. The books are still good and Sanderson really ties a bow on the series at the end.
reply
305 sats \ 1 reply \ @Scoresby 7 Feb
Excellent write up! I was debating whether to read these or not, and the parts of the amazon show I watched made me wonder if it was worth it. You make it sound very interesting. Gotta love some well-done world building.
reply
I had a sense from the show that the books might go into a lot of depth beyond what we see in the show and that's definitely true.
The events are also sufficiently different that the show barely spoils the books.
reply
deleted by author
reply