It's never just about carbon. You obviously know that when you mentioned farming which tackles methane.
It IS effective, whether EFFICIENT way to cut down emissions is another question.
I am also not sure what you mean scale doesn't support the science.
You don't need hundreds of years of record to know if you have a model of X + Y = Z, which has been verified with real life live data repeatedly and simulation.
Do you think we need light years of record to prove gravity exists?
And we are all bitcoiners here, we are risk averse to protect Bitcoin against any attacks. Somehow we should be open to the idea that we shouldn't wear any seatbelts and just let things be, even if the risk is life threatening globally